Index bloat occurs when too many URLs that do not belong in search results are indexed. Keyword overlap occurs when multiple pages target or rank for the same keywords, potentially competing with one another. The two can occur together, but they are not the same. With index bloat, the task is to identify URLs that should not be indexed. With keyword overlap, it is to check whether pages serve the same search intent and whether their competition is harmful. Possible responses include pruning low-value content, refocusing pages, or consolidating them. A large number of URLs alone does not justify deletion, nor are multiple pages targeting the same keyword necessarily harmful.
Problems can stem from URL generation or overlapping content plans
A 2021 overview from Screaming Frog noted that features such as filters, internal search, tracking parameters, categories, and tags can all generate indexable URLs. User-generated content, programming errors, and overlooked subdomains are also worth investigating. Pages from these sources are not necessarily low-quality; the key question is whether large numbers of them have accumulated without needing to appear in search results.
Content planning can also cause problems. For example, repeatedly publishing articles targeting the same keyword without clearly distinguishing their topics and purposes may make it difficult for search engines to determine which URL to prioritize. However, if multiple pages targeting the same keyword can rank highly at the same time, intervention may not be necessary. Keyword overlap alone does not establish that performance has suffered. At Procrustes, our services also include planning content topics for the websites we work on, as well as writing and updating that content.
Look for overlooked URLs and clarify search intent
- Take stock of potentially overlooked URLs: Check HTTP and HTTPS versions of URLs as well as subdomains, rather than examining only the main site. Review XML sitemaps for URLs you do not want indexed, such as tag pages.
- Cross-check data: For large sites suspected of severe index bloat, combine site crawl results, Search Console, and traffic data to find pages that a crawl following internal links alone might miss. An indexable URL is not necessarily an indexed URL.
- Review overlapping pages in groups: A 2024 Semrush article recommends identifying URLs with overlapping keywords, then checking whether the pages address the same topic or search intent and which page is better suited to each keyword. Unstable rankings, declining search visibility, or an unexpected page ranking are clues worth investigating. On their own, however, they do not prove that competition between pages is causing harm.
Choose whether to keep, rewrite, or consolidate pages based on their value
If a page still offers value in search but its tone is unsuitable or its content does not fit the intended audience’s needs, update the content and supporting explanations rather than deleting it outright. Orphan pages with no internal links pointing to them are not necessarily low-quality either; links to those worth keeping can be restored.
If two pages are confirmed to serve the same purpose and their competition is causing problems, you can adjust one page’s content and internal link anchor text to give the pages distinct roles. Alternatively, combine the strengths of both pages, retain the better-performing URL where possible, and redirect the other page to it. Low-quality pages, empty pages, and duplicate pages with little value worth preserving are candidates for pruning or exclusion from search results. Base the decision on the content’s value and fit for its intended audience, rather than simply reducing the number of URLs.
Index bloat and keyword overlap: perspectives from across the web
Why does pagination on large e-commerce sites deserve particular attention?
When pagination is handled poorly, individual pages in a series may be indexed separately and compete with one another in search results. A 2019 Semrush article noted that large e-commerce sites with many product styles, colors, or sizes may be particularly susceptible to index bloat, which may also consume crawl budget on large sites. This does not mean that all paginated pages should be excluded from the index. Assessments should take both site size and page purpose into account.
Are Search Console reports alone enough to audit a large site?
Not necessarily. In 2021, Screaming Frog noted that the URL data in the report it described was based on the last crawl and might not reflect the latest state, and that the report listed no more than 1,000 URLs. For large sites suspected of severe index bloat, that report alone might not be sufficient. Site crawls and other data can be used to cross-check it. These are descriptions of a specific report in a historical article and should not be treated as current limitations.
References
- Conducting an SEO Content Audit: 6 Things You Might Be Overlookingwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2021-11-15T13:37:48+00:00 — Discusses: Are Search Console reports alone enough to audit a large site?
- How to Track Keywords: Tips, Examples & Checklistwww.semrush.com · 2024-04-29T18:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Pagination: You’re Doing It Wrong! (Part 1)www.semrush.com · 2019-01-21T09:00:00Z — Discusses: Why does pagination on large e-commerce sites deserve particular attention?

