Identifying index bloat is not about how many pages a website has, but whether search engines have indexed large numbers of URLs that are not worth indexing, such as blank, low-quality, duplicate, or heavily overlapping pages. Cross-reference indexing data, website crawl results, and XML sitemaps, then check whether the flagged pages offer valuable content. Absence from a sitemap, a lack of internal links, or similar content are only clues to investigate; none alone establishes index bloat.
First, define the scope of the audit—look beyond the main site
Screaming Frog’s 2021 article recommends covering HTTP, HTTPS, and subdomains in the audit. The author prefers using a Domain property in Search Console to view them together and avoid overlooking low-value pages on subdomains. This is the article’s audit recommendation, not a claim that every subdomain has problems.
Next, check whether the XML sitemap focuses on valuable pages you want indexed. Pay particular attention to tag pages and pagination URLs that the system adds automatically but that you do not actually want indexed.
Cross-reference URLs and distinguish indexable from indexed
The same article recommends combining website crawl results with Analytics and Search Console API data to find additional URLs that a standard crawl may not reach. Then compare those URLs with the sitemap. Compile lists of the following:
- Indexed URLs missing from the sitemap: check each page to determine whether it is still worth indexing.
- URLs found during a crawl but missing from the sitemap: check their content and indexing status before treating them as unnecessary.
- Non-indexable URLs in the sitemap: check whether each page’s current status is consistent with the original aim of having it indexed.
- Orphan pages with no internal links: determine whether their content is worth keeping.
Being indexable does not mean being indexed. These lists help narrow the audit’s scope; not every flagged URL represents index bloat.
Prioritize spot checks of page types that generate large numbers of URLs
Check URLs generated by filters, internal search results, tracking parameters, categories, tags, and pagination. Also look for blank pages and multiple articles repeatedly covering the same topic. Content similarity filters can help identify duplicate or near-duplicate pages, but human review is still needed to determine whether each page offers distinct value.
Semrush’s 2019 article specifically notes that improperly handled pagination can cause index bloat. Large e-commerce sites offering many product styles, colors, or sizes deserve particular attention. This does not mean all paginated pages should be excluded from the index, and the explanation from that year should not be treated as current platform rules.
Make the final assessment based on content value, not a single signal
Orphan pages are not necessarily low-quality; internal links can be restored to valuable ones. Multiple pages targeting the same keyword are not necessarily harmful either. First check whether the content lacks distinct value, duplicates other content, or competes with it. Then decide whether the relevant pages are worth keeping in the index. Taken together, these recommendations call for combining several methods when auditing large websites suspected of severe index bloat, rather than drawing conclusions from a single URL list.
Index bloat: perspectives from across the web
What level of content similarity qualifies as index bloat?
There is no similarity threshold that directly establishes index bloat. Screaming Frog’s 2021 article states that its tool used a default threshold of 90% to identify similar pages at the time, and that this threshold could be adjusted. This figure is a tool setting for finding pages to review, not a search engine rule. You still need to confirm whether the pages are indexed and whether their content offers distinct value.
Are Search Console’s URL lists sufficient for auditing large websites?
It is best not to rely on a single report. Screaming Frog’s 2021 article states that the report used in the article was based on the last crawl, might not reflect the latest status, and listed a maximum of 1,000 URLs. Large websites can also combine website crawls with Analytics and Search Console data to investigate URLs that a crawl may not reach. These limitations are historical descriptions from that article and should not be treated as current rules.
If multiple pages target the same keyword, must they be excluded from the index?
Not necessarily. Screaming Frog’s 2021 article argues that multiple pages on the same site targeting the same keyword are not inherently harmful: if they can rank highly at the same time, that may be a good outcome. However, the pages may also compete with one another, resulting in poor organic search visibility. First check whether the content is duplicated and whether each page offers distinct value, then decide whether action is needed.
References
- Conducting an SEO Content Audit: 6 Things You Might Be Overlookingwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2021-11-15T13:37:48+00:00 — Discusses: What level of content similarity qualifies as index bloat?; Are Search Console’s URL lists sufficient for auditing large websites?
- Pagination: You’re Doing It Wrong! (Part 1)www.semrush.com · 2019-01-21T09:00:00Z — Source used in the article above.

