To distinguish in-depth articles from blog-style posts, start with how the content addresses an issue and how readers engage with it, rather than the software the website uses. In his 2007 analysis, Jakob Nielsen described in-depth articles as comprehensive explorations of a topic. By contrast, he characterized blog-style posts as a series of short, frequently updated pieces responding to the day’s hot topics. This is his framework for classifying content, not a definition that all blogs must fit; a piece published on a blogging platform can also be an in-depth article.
Three key distinctions: depth, originality, and what drives the writing
Nielsen distinguished the two formats not just by length, but by what the content offers:
- Depth: Does it guide readers through a comprehensive exploration of the topic, or offer only a brief comment?
- Source of the content: Does it offer original, firsthand material, or is it primarily derived from others’ work?
- What drives the writing: Is it grounded in the author’s expertise, or does it mainly respond to content on other websites and external events?
A piece therefore cannot be considered in-depth simply because it is long, nor should it be classified as brief commentary merely because it appears on a blog. Under this framework, the real question is whether readers receive a complete explanation or a series of immediate responses as events unfold.
Demonstrating expertise or joining the current discussion?
If the goal is to demonstrate expertise in depth, Nielsen’s advice favors writing in-depth articles regularly. He once advised a leading expert in a field on website content: with limited time, the expert should focus on comprehensive articles rather than spread their efforts across numerous brief responses to blog discussions. This advice was specific to that situation; it does not mean that all authors should avoid short posts.
If the aim is to join an ongoing discussion, brief commentary also has its uses. Nielsen argued that this kind of content is easy to write and may generate controversy and short-term traffic; that is his assessment, not a guarantee of traffic. He also acknowledged that blogs have a role in business settings, citing project blogs as an example.
Ask again: will it still make sense outside its original context?
Nielsen’s main criticism of brief commentary was that it may not provide lasting value. He described readers searching for an answer to a problem, only to find a short post from a debate that took place years earlier and is no longer relevant. This reminds editors to consider whether content depends too heavily on its original context; it does not mean that all older posts are useless.
For example, a brief opinion responding solely to a popular article is closer to what he described as blog-style commentary. A comprehensive exploration of the same issue, grounded in the author’s expertise, is closer to an in-depth article, even if it uses the same platform. These examples illustrate the criteria above. When choosing a format, first clarify whether the aim is to help readers fully understand an issue or to respond to the current discussion.
As part of our content services at Procrustes, we turn the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
In-depth articles and blog-style posts: common questions
Does a piece qualify as an in-depth article simply because it is long?
Length alone is not enough. Under the classification Jakob Nielsen proposed in 2007, other considerations include whether the content covers the topic comprehensively, offers original or firsthand material, and is driven by the author's expertise. A long piece that mainly relays others' views cannot be classified as an in-depth article solely because of its word count; this is a judgment about content, not a fixed word-count threshold.
Which format is suitable when responding to someone else's work?
If the aim is to join an ongoing discussion, brief commentary can be used to respond to others' work. If the aim is to give readers a complete understanding of an issue, consider a more comprehensive article grounded in your own expertise. Nielsen argued that brief commentary is easy to write and may generate controversy and short-term traffic, but its lasting value may be limited if the original debate is no longer relevant years later.
Should expert authors with limited time prioritize in-depth articles or frequent brief commentary?
Nielsen once advised a leading expert in a field to write in-depth articles regularly rather than devote limited time to numerous brief responses to discussions. This advice applied to his assessment of that expert's website content at the time; it should not be taken to mean that all authors should abandon short posts. He also acknowledged that blogs have a role in business settings, such as project blogs.
References
- Write Articles, Not Blog Postingswww.nngroup.com · 2007-07-09T05:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Does a piece qualify as an in-depth article simply because it is long?; Which format is suitable when responding to someone else's work?


