The main benefit of switching a website to HTTPS is that it encrypts data transmitted between the browser and server. This is particularly important for sites that handle logins, payments, and personal information. HTTPS may also increase visitor trust, but it does not guarantee higher rankings or conversion rates. When deciding whether to switch, consider not just certificate installation but also the work needed to manage redirects, links, and indexing settings. A poorly managed migration can lead to mixed content, confusion between old and new site versions, and fluctuations in search traffic.
Prioritize protection in transit, not ranking gains
Semrush explains that HTTP transmits data in plain text, while HTTPS encrypts it in transit, reducing the risk of someone accessing login credentials, payment information, and browsing activity. For pages that require users to enter credit card information, encryption meets a practical security need rather than simply helping search visibility.
However, HTTPS protects data transmitted between the browser and the website’s server; it does not mean the entire website is completely secure. Semrush also suggests that a sense of security may make visitors more willing to stay or make a transaction, but it does not provide a conversion-rate increase that applies to every website.
SEO may benefit, but migration can still cause fluctuations
A Semrush article dated 2020 lists HTTPS as a Google ranking signal; awoo’s 2024 article also suggests that a properly managed switch may improve rankings. However, research cited in Neil Patel’s 2016 article shows only a limited correlation between HTTPS and higher rankings, and the article cautions against migrating solely for SEO. These sources do not establish that switching to HTTPS alone will increase organic traffic, nor should they be used to determine how much weight HTTPS currently carries in rankings.
A past example also highlights the risk of traffic fluctuations during migration. Neil Patel’s article reports that after Buffer switched in 2014, its organic traffic temporarily fell by 90% and recovered after about 20 days. The article says this involved an unexpected issue related to search engines. The decline and recovery time in this case are not representative of a typical migration, nor do they establish that HTTPS itself causes traffic to fall.
After installing the certificate, keep URLs and resources consistent
awoo’s 2024 article lists the following migration tasks, focusing on managing old and new URLs and ensuring that page resources also use HTTPS:
- Handle old URLs: Use 301 redirects to send HTTP pages to their corresponding HTTPS pages so search engines can recognize the new locations.
- Update links and canonical URLs: Change internal links, public URLs you control on social media or other websites, and the URLs in canonical tags to HTTPS. Submit an HTTPS sitemap in Search Console as well.
- Check for mixed content: A page that uses HTTPS but still loads images or videos over HTTP is an example of mixed content. Checking the address bar alone is therefore not enough.
If configured incorrectly, both HTTP and HTTPS versions may be indexed. Mixed content may also affect security and the visitor experience. When evaluating whether to switch, account for these checks and fixes rather than considering only the cost of obtaining a certificate.
Switching a website to HTTPS: perspectives from across the web
Could visitors be unable to access the website after it switches to HTTPS?
Visitors using mainstream browsers generally should not lose access because of the switch, but those using extremely outdated software may be affected. Semrush notes that major browsers such as Chrome, Firefox, Microsoft Edge, and Safari have long supported HTTPS. If your visitors may rely on older devices or browsers, consider their compatibility needs when deciding whether to switch.
Will switching to HTTPS necessarily make the website noticeably slower?
Not necessarily. awoo notes that HTTPS connections involve an additional handshake step. In the company's experience, the switch did slow the site down, but not noticeably. That experience does not mean every website will see the same change; you still need to assess the likely impact on your own site.
Could certificate and encryption costs make the switch not worthwhile?
Whether the switch is worthwhile depends on the site's budget and expected benefits, not just the certificate price. Free certificates are available, but there are other costs to consider. Neil Patel's 2016 article notes that paid certificates were also available at the time and that data encryption costs could increase for large websites. It therefore recommends weighing the budget against the benefits. The prices and cost assessment reflect conditions at the time, not a current quote.
References
- HTTPS 的威力?「S」對 SEO 與網站經營的五大重要性www.awoo.ai · 2024-07-21T16:03:45+00:00 — Discusses: Will switching to HTTPS necessarily make the website noticeably slower?
- What Is HTTPS & How Does It Work? [Explained]www.semrush.com · 2020-07-31T13:00:00Z — Discusses: Could visitors be unable to access the website after it switches to HTTPS?
- Do SSL Certificates Affect Search Rankings? (A Data Driven Answer…)neilpatel.com · 2016-07-06T20:47:14+00:00 — Discusses: Could certificate and encryption costs make the switch not worthwhile?



