Changing the first H2 to an H1 may increase organic traffic, but it does not guarantee a gain for every website. In a travel industry case study published by SearchPilot in 2025, the team tested listing pages that originally had no H1. They changed the first H2 to an H1 while keeping the existing visual styling. In the expanded test, the pages receiving this change—the variant group—saw a statistically significant 4.5% increase in organic traffic. However, an earlier test of the same change on fewer pages was inconclusive. This was a result for a specific page template, not a general rule that adding an H1 guarantees growth.
The heading hierarchy changed, not the page’s appearance
The client was in the travel industry, and the test covered listing pages that originally had no H1. The team changed the first H2 on each page to an H1 but kept its styling, so users saw no change in appearance. The result therefore reflects a change to the heading tag, not an increase in font size or a redesigned layout.
- The test concerned pages that originally had no H1, not pages receiving an additional H1.
- The change applied to the first H2, not to every H2 on the page.
- The case study provides no validation for other industries or page types, so the same increase cannot be assumed elsewhere.
The smaller test was inconclusive; the expanded test showed a significant gain
The team initially tested the change on a small number of pages. Traffic appeared unaffected, but an inconclusive result did not prove that the change had no effect. Suspecting that there was too little traffic to draw a clear conclusion, the team expanded the test to all listing pages using that template, quadrupling the number of pages.
After the expansion, the variant group recorded a 4.5% increase in organic traffic. The case study also estimated that rolling out the change across the entire page section could generate approximately 3,000 additional sessions per month. This monthly increase was a projection, not a measured result following a full rollout. The difference between the two tests does not mean that “the more pages there are, the stronger the effect of an H1.” The larger test provided more data, but the case study does not establish that testing more pages improves the effect on any individual page.
Traffic increased, but the cause was not directly verified
The test hypothesis was that changing the first heading to an H1 would help search engines understand the page structure, leading to greater relevance, better rankings and more organic traffic. Author Daniel Haugen suggested that the increase might be due to Google finding it easier to understand the page content, particularly when handling localized queries.
However, the case study also noted that the absolute differences in rankings and click-through rates were very small. The experiment therefore showed an increase in organic traffic, but did not directly establish that better understanding by Google was the cause. Nor can the increase be attributed entirely to improved rankings or click-through rates. For other pages that currently have no H1, this case study supports considering the same adjustment for testing, rather than promising a 4.5% gain in advance.
Changing the first H2 to an H1: perspectives from across the web
Can people’s expectations about this change serve as evidence of its impact on traffic?
A poll alone cannot predict the actual outcome. In the poll accompanying SearchPilot’s case study, most respondents expected an inconclusive or positive result, and none expected organic traffic to decline. However, this reflects respondents’ judgments before the test, not evidence that other websites cannot experience negative results. The actual impact still needs to be evaluated under conditions relevant to your own pages.
References
- Does Changing an H2 to an H1 Improve Organic Traffic?www.searchpilot.com · 2025-06-06T15:57:17.000Z — Discusses: Can people’s expectations about this change serve as evidence of its impact on traffic?


