When setting up an H1, first identify the question the page should answer. Then use a clear main heading to express the topic and include relevant keywords naturally. When updating an existing page, also check for a missing H1, a logical subheading hierarchy, and consistency between the H1, title tag, and body content. A page focused on a single topic can use one main H1 with H2 and H3 headings to organize the content, but adding tags or keywords does not guarantee higher rankings.
Check the Existing Structure—Do Not Turn All Large Text into H1 Headings
Semrush recommends using the H1 to describe the page topic, H2 headings to mark the main sections, and H3 headings to identify subsections. A clear hierarchy helps readers and screen reader users navigate the page; it is not just for search engines.
- Missing or empty H1: Add one, starting with important pages you want to appear in search results.
- Existing main heading: Check that it accurately summarizes the content and makes the page topic clear.
- Subheadings: Use H2 and H3 headings to show which topics are at the same level and which belong within others. Do not make every section heading a main heading.
“One main H1 per page” is a structural recommendation here, not a rule whose violation triggers a search engine penalty. A Stack Exchange discussion suggested that HTML5 sections can each have their own H1, but the respondent explicitly said they were unsure how search engines handled this at the time. That discussion therefore offers no guarantee about the SEO effects of multiple H1 headings.
Use the H1 to Describe the Content, Not Just to Insert Search Terms
Keywords should help readers identify the content and match the answers the page actually provides. Semrush recommends understanding search intent first, then making sure the H1 and body content address readers’ needs. You can check whether related search results focus on explanations, comparisons, or purchasing information, but you should not simply change the heading while leaving mismatched content in place.
As part of our content services at Procrustes, we turn the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
On product category pages, the H1 should make the category especially clear. Search Engine Journal recommends mentioning the main product category in the H1 and placing brand slogans in regular paragraphs instead. For example, if a page lists hiking boots, the H1 could be “Hiking Boots” rather than just “Step Into Your Next Adventure.” This is an editorial example, not a tested case demonstrating traffic gains.
Check That the H1 and Title Tag Describe the Same Page Content
The H1 is the visible main heading on the page; the title tag appears in the browser tab and may also be used in search results. They serve different purposes but should describe the same page content. For article pages, Semrush recommends making them identical or very similar. For non-article pages, they may differ to accommodate a brand name, a product value proposition, or other needs; they do not have to match word for word.
For example, if a tutorial’s H1 is “How to Choose Hiking Boots,” its title tag should not promise a ranking by price that the body content does not provide. The key is to check that both describe the same topic and that the content meets the expectations they set, rather than simply copying text. Google may still use the H1, subheadings, or page content to rewrite the search result title, so matching the H1 and title tag does not guarantee that search results will display the original wording.
Setting up and optimizing H1 headings: perspectives from across the web
Does an H1 have to stay within 60 characters?
No. There is no need to treat 60 characters as a technical limit. Semrush recommends concise H1 headings and suggests fewer than 60 characters as a guideline. Some content management systems use the same text for the H1 and title tag, and Google sometimes uses the H1 as the search result title. If that text is too long, it may be truncated in search results. This is writing guidance, not a hard rule that every page must follow.
Do you still need to add an H1 manually when using a content management system?
Not necessarily. First check whether the article title is already set as the H1 automatically, then decide whether to add one. Semrush’s article notes that many content management systems automatically make the article title an H1. Adding one manually without checking could leave the page with an extra, unintended H1. The right approach still depends on the system and theme, so inspect the tags in the rendered page.
Will changing the heading structure definitely increase traffic?
There is no guarantee. In SearchPilot’s case study, a statistically significant traffic increase was observed after the change was expanded to an entire section of the website, but the absolute differences in rankings and click-through rates were very small. The author suggested that the structural change may have helped Google understand the content, particularly for localized queries. This is an interpretation of that case, not a basis for assuming that other websites—or changes to the H1 alone—would see the same results.
References
- SEO regarding using separate <h1> tags for the logo and website namewebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- What Is an H1 Tag? Why It Matters & Best Practices for SEOwww.semrush.com · 2020-12-18T12:00:00Z — Discusses: Does an H1 have to stay within 60 characters?; Do you still need to add an H1 manually when using a content management system?
- Does Changing an H2 to an H1 Improve Organic Traffic?www.searchpilot.com · 2025-06-06T15:57:17.000Z — Discusses: Will changing the heading structure definitely increase traffic?
- How Do I Split Pages Between Brand Building & Converting? – Ask An SEOwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-07-16T09:30:23+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- How to Run a Successful SEO Campaign in 2025www.semrush.com · 2020-11-05T15:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- How to Write SEO Headlines That Rank (+ 9 Powerful Templates)www.semrush.com · 2023-08-03T08:50:00Z — Source used in the article above.


