To track Google algorithm updates, first confirm the update’s type, purpose, and start and end dates, then compare your website’s search performance before and after the update. A sustained decline in clicks, impressions, and rankings that aligns with the update’s timing is a stronger sign that your site may have been affected. Overlapping timing does not prove causation; seasonality, changes in competition, and tracking errors must also be considered. Before responding, wait for the initial fluctuations to settle, then prioritize reviewing the most affected pages rather than overhauling the entire site as soon as traffic drops.
Confirm the update first—do not treat volatility tools as official announcements
Use the Google Search Status Dashboard to check the start and end dates of confirmed updates. Then consult Google Search Central announcements to understand each update’s type and purpose—for example, whether it is a core update or a spam update. Google Alerts, industry publications, and newsletters can provide additional news.
MozCast, Semrush Sensor, and AccuRanker Grump provide signals of search result volatility. Semrush Sensor’s category and device data can help you assess whether changes are widespread across your industry. These data provide market context; they cannot independently prove that a particular update affected your website.
Compare performance before and after, from the whole site to individual pages
In Search Console, compare clicks, impressions, and average position before and after the update. Then examine which pages declined and which improved, while continuing to track important keywords. You can compare periods of equal length, but this still does not rule out external factors.
- Examine search types such as web, image, and video separately to avoid mixing their results.
- Use GA4 organic search sessions and engagement rate as supplementary indicators rather than drawing a conclusion from a traffic decline alone.
- Record pages with significant ranking declines to create a checklist for further review.
In its 2024 overview of the core update guidance available at the time, Welly summarized a recommendation to wait about a week after an update finishes before analyzing its impact. This recommendation is specific to a particular period and update type; it should not be treated as a fixed rule that currently applies to all updates.
Look for alternative explanations when assessing the impact
A sharp, sustained decline in search performance during a confirmed update is a signal worth investigating, but a before-and-after comparison is not a controlled experiment. Seasonality and changes in competition can both affect results. If no update has been confirmed, it is especially important to check whether tracking is working correctly, whether search demand has fallen, and whether the website has user experience problems such as broken links.
You can also look for shared patterns in the ranking gains and losses of pages in your field, and check whether competing pages cover topics missing from your own content. This can guide your review, but it is not enough to establish the exact reason Google lowered a page’s ranking.
Prioritize action once rankings stabilize, and focus improvements on readers’ needs
Once ranking changes have stabilized, prioritize affected pages according to their importance for traffic or conversions. Check whether the content fully answers readers’ questions and whether the information is accurate and up to date. For example, if a “best software” recommendation page heavily promotes your own products, assess whether it has strayed from readers’ need to compare options. The response should not be simply to make the page longer. As part of our content services at Procrustes, we turn the questions clients genuinely care about into articles through ongoing planning, writing, and updating. Continue monitoring performance after revising content, but remember that improvements do not guarantee a recovery in rankings.
Perspectives from across the web
Does a ranking drop after a core update mean the website has violated Google’s guidelines?
Not necessarily. Worse performance after a core update may also mean that other pages are performing better relative to yours; it does not automatically indicate a guideline violation. The advice cited by Semrush is to avoid rushing to find a single “fix” and instead keep improving content quality. The content may perform better relative to other pages in the future, but ranking recovery is not guaranteed.
Can you still compare keyword rankings before and after an update if you did not establish a baseline beforehand?
You may be able to reconstruct a baseline, depending on the data your tool retains. A 2018 Semrush article demonstrates how to export keyword rankings from its index, separate pre-update and post-update data by the date they were last checked, and then compare ranking changes. This only covers keywords the tool had indexed and checked at the time. The interface and steps shown in the article should not be treated as current procedures.
Do content improvements always require firsthand experience?
Not always, and you should not invent experience to improve rankings. Welly recommends sharing firsthand experience where appropriate, or interviewing people with relevant experience, to make content more convincing—provided that the experience is genuine and relevant to readers’ needs. If no firsthand experience is available, you can start by reviewing the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and coverage.
References
- 2024 8 月演算法更新懶人包!更新重點+4 方法面對演算法更新!welly.tw · 2024-09-19T02:55:27.670Z — Discusses: Do content improvements always require firsthand experience?
- Google Search Algorithm Changes: 2026 Updateneilpatel.com · 2026-05-06T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Discusses: Does a ranking drop after a core update mean the website has violated Google’s guidelines?
- The Guide to Finding Keywords You Ranked or Lost After a Google Algorithm Updatewww.semrush.com · 2018-08-15T07:00:00Z — Discusses: Can you still compare keyword rankings before and after an update if you did not establish a baseline beforehand?
- SEO Testing: What It Is & How to Test SEO in 2025 (+ 6 Ideas)www.semrush.com · 2024-03-21T10:44:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Google Algorithm Updates Timeline [2024-2009]www.semrush.com · 2021-03-30T08:00:00Z — Discusses: Does a ranking drop after a core update mean the website has violated Google’s guidelines?
- How the Google Search Algorithm Works: A Zero-Fluff Guidewww.semrush.com · 2021-10-07T19:19:00Z — Source used in the article above.


