An existing blog and a new website: keep the old site and gradually define the new one’s role

ProcrustesPR

If an existing blog is still working well, a more cautious approach is to keep it running, build a new website in the same niche on your own domain, and gradually guide readers there, rather than shut down the old site immediately. The old blog can continue publishing content and attracting readers, while the new website offers full articles, landing pages, and subscription options where the necessary features are supported. Whether you need to maintain both sites still depends on their purposes and the maintenance workload. The advice below mainly concerns keeping an existing Blogspot blog while building a new site; it is not a universal answer for all websites.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Define each site’s role first—they do not need to do exactly the same thing

Stephen Crooks recommends continuing to run the existing Blogspot blog while building a website in the same niche on your own domain, then gradually guiding readers to the new site. Monetize also suggests keeping an existing blog if it has no problems, setting up a separate self-hosted website, and using links and a subscriber list to help the two sites work together.

Based on these suggestions, the two sites could divide their roles as follows:

  • Existing blog: Continue updating it and include links to the new site in relevant content.
  • New website: Offer full content or dedicated landing pages for readers arriving from the old site.
  • Connecting the two: Gradually add links between the sites’ content. Launching a new site does not mean you need to abandon the old one immediately.

Give readers a specific destination—links are not a ranking guarantee

maxdosh proposes two practical approaches: place links on the free blog that take readers to a landing page on the new website, or publish shortened articles on the old site and direct interested readers to the new site for the full versions. For example, the old site could offer an article summary while the new site hosts the full version; the article does not need to be the same length on both sites.

maxdosh also suggests building a subscriber list but explicitly says they are unsure whether a subscription form can be added to the free website. Before using this approach, check whether the platform supports that feature. Andrew Caron notes that a new site takes time to gain search rankings. He recommends keeping the old site and adding relevant links, but this does not guarantee that search rankings will improve.

Whether to maintain both sites depends on their purposes and the resources available

The PTT discussion offers differing views: one participant argues that the company website should remain the main site, with the blog in a supporting role, to preserve the main site’s structure. A respondent, however, argues that if the company website consists mainly of static text and images, a blog might replace it without necessarily compromising the content structure.

The division of roles should therefore not depend solely on labels such as “official website” or “blog.” Before deciding, establish whether the content is mainly text and images, who will handle updates, and whether you have the resources to manage hosting, bandwidth, and renewals. The costs and search performance mentioned in that post reflect statements and individual cases from that time; they should not be treated as current prices or promises of results.

At Procrustes, we also build a separate website as part of our service, without requiring changes to the client’s existing company website. This is one way to keep an existing site while building a new one; whether it is suitable still depends on the sites’ purposes and the resources available to maintain them.

If you decide to keep both sites, first clarify what content each will offer and which needs it will meet, then plan the updates.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow do I write SEO articles that help my business?

Existing blogs and new websites: perspectives from across the web

If an existing blog is working well, is a separate new website still necessary?

Not necessarily. If the old blog still meets your needs, the decision to add a website should also take management resources into account. One forum participant recommends building a separate site to reduce risk but does not specify the risks involved; another suggests keeping the functioning old site and setting up a separate self-hosted website. These are options for running the sites, not grounds for concluding that a new site is necessarily safer.

Does a company website have to be retained if it has little content?

Not necessarily—the key considerations are its existing structure and purpose. In the PTT discussion, one participant argues that the company website should be the main site and the blog should only support it. A respondent, however, argues that if the company website consists mainly of static text and images, a blog might accommodate its existing content structure. These are differing assessments based on the nature of the website; the decision should not be made on labels alone.

Will the old site’s search rankings transfer directly to the new site once it is built?

You should not expect rankings to transfer directly to a new domain. Forum respondents note that a new site takes time to gain rankings, so they recommend continuing to run the old blog and using links to guide readers to the new site. This is advice for managing the transition, not a guarantee that adding links will secure any particular ranking for the new site.

ProcrustesPRDo SEO articles have to be long?

References

  1. Re: [閒聊] 用部落格架設公司網站www.ptt.cc — Discusses: Does a company website have to be retained if it has little content?
  2. New domain parking seo factwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: If an existing blog is working well, is a separate new website still necessary?
  3. New domain parking seo factwww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  4. New domain parking seo factwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: If an existing blog is working well, is a separate new website still necessary?
  5. New domain parking seo factwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Will the old site’s search rankings transfer directly to the new site once it is built?
  6. New domain parking seo factwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Will the old site’s search rankings transfer directly to the new site once it is built?

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?How do I write SEO articles that help my business?Do SEO articles have to be long?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: Website contentAI Makes Marketing Harder. Don’t Expect an Easy Ride.What Is Content Marketing? Turning Helpful Content into Business ResultsWhat Is Integrated Marketing? Connecting Content, Search, Social Media, and EmailHow Do B2B Companies Use Blogs and Content Management Systems?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR