Can desktop site-wide navigation have more than 7–9 top-level categories?

ProcrustesPR

Yes. Desktop site-wide navigation does not have to be limited to 7–9 top-level categories, but the number should suit the information architecture and navigation format. When a website covers a broad range of information, merging categories just to fit a horizontal navigation bar can make labels vague and content harder to find. A 2021 NN/g article notes that left-side vertical navigation can accommodate more top-level items, displaying specific categories directly. The point is not to maximize the number of items, but to keep layout constraints from making categories harder to recognize.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDoes my website need a speed score of 100?

Assess how specific the categories are before aiming for a fixed number

Fewer top-level categories do not necessarily make information easier to find. If a broad range of content is grouped into a few large categories, users may have to open a vaguely labeled option and then scan its subcategories to determine whether it contains what they need. The NN/g article specifically argues against reducing top-level categories solely to fit the available space.

The article uses Accenture’s website at the time as an example: information about many services was grouped under a single “Services” category, making specific consulting service areas harder to find. Users had to open categories, scan options, and rule out irrelevant items more often. This is a historical example described in the article, not a claim that the website still uses the same design.

Before deciding whether to merge categories, consider three questions:

  • Do category labels indicate what is inside, rather than merely serving as broad umbrella terms?
  • Does reducing top-level items simply make users look for specific options at the next level?
  • Are categories being merged solely because they do not fit in the horizontal navigation bar?

Consider left-side vertical navigation when you need to show more categories

A horizontal navigation bar is not the only option for primary desktop navigation. When a website needs to display more top-level categories, left-side vertical navigation avoids the space constraints of a horizontal layout. Categories can better reflect the scope of the content without hiding specific options inside broad groups just to fit everything into one row.

The Arbor Restaurant example in the same article presents 13 site-wide categories in vertical navigation. The author notes that this arrangement makes the main categories more specific and gives them stronger “information scent”: users can anticipate the content from the labels without first selecting a broadly labeled category to see specific options. The number 13 comes from this example; it is not a standard that every website should adopt.

When items do not fit, do not sacrifice text size and spacing

For navigation with many categories and limited horizontal space, the NN/g article identifies three common problems: making fonts too small, placing items too close together, and using unnaturally short labels to save space. These approaches merely try to squeeze options into a single row; they do not resolve the mismatch between the navigation format and the information architecture.

When there are more than 7–9 top-level categories, review how specific the categories are and whether the navigation format suits them, rather than immediately cutting items. If retaining specific categories saves users an extra level of navigation, left-side vertical navigation is worth considering. This does not mean that more categories are always better.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPREight SEO essentials for beginners: Website speed

Top-level categories in desktop site-wide navigation: perspectives from across the web

Do top-level categories have to be merged when there are more than nine?

Not necessarily. If a website covers a broad range of information, first consider whether the merged category labels would still help users recognize the content. Reducing categories solely to fit the layout can create overly broad groupings, forcing users to repeatedly scan lower levels. This does not mean that more categories are always better, however.

When is left-side vertical navigation worth considering?

Consider left-side vertical navigation when a desktop website covers a broad range of content and needs to display multiple specific categories directly. Unlike a horizontal navigation bar, it is not constrained by the available width in the same way, so it can show more categories directly. Users can anticipate the content from the labels without first opening a broadly labeled category to see specific options.

If items do not fit in horizontal navigation, can you shrink the text or shorten the labels?

Avoid making fonts too small, placing items too close together, or using unnaturally short labels to save space. When there are many categories and limited horizontal space, these approaches create design problems. Consider a different navigation format rather than simply trying to squeeze every item into one row.

ProcrustesPRWhat Ten Years of SEO Taught Me About Its Real Purpose

References

  1. Left-Side Vertical Navigation on Desktop: Scalable, Responsive, and Easy to Scanwww.nngroup.com · 2021-05-16T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Do top-level categories have to be merged when there are more than nine?; When is left-side vertical navigation worth considering?

Related articles

Does my website need a speed score of 100?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: Website speedWhat Ten Years of SEO Taught Me About Its Real PurposeHow Do RWD and AWD Work, and Which Should You Choose for Your Website?What are the benefits and development challenges of SPAs?How do UTF-8 and Big5 differ in their effects on search rankings and user experience?What are single-page websites best suited for, and what are their pros and cons?Keep different topics on one site or split them up? Start with audience overlap and maintenance capacity
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR