Finding that Google has selected a URL on another domain as canonical is not enough to conclude that a cross-domain canonical caused deindexing. First, confirm the site’s actual configuration, Google’s selected canonical URL, and whether Google received normal content when it crawled the page. In the reported case, different URLs displaying identical application error pages are a possible but unconfirmed explanation. The unusual canonical selection may have resulted from Google treating error content as duplicate content, rather than being the cause of the indexing issue.
First, distinguish between the site’s configuration and Google’s selection
Search Engine Journal reported in September 2026 that a Reddit user said their company’s and suppliers’ pages were gradually being deindexed, while Google was selecting casino pages as canonical. This was the user’s observation; it does not directly establish that the site had canonical tags pointing to a casino, nor does it prove that Google’s selection and the deindexing were causally related.
- Verify the actual tags: Do your pages actually declare a cross-domain canonical? Do not mistake Google’s selected URL for the site’s original configuration.
- Check the target’s response: An article by Neil Patel published that same month noted that a canonical pointing to a page that returns a non-200 status code, such as a 404 or a redirect, may hinder Google’s ability to identify the site’s preferred page.
- Rule out conflicts: Multiple conflicting canonicals on the same page may also cause confusion. However, finding a configuration problem does not prove that it caused deindexing.
Different pages may have displayed the same error message
The user later discovered that the search result title for the third-party URL was a generic JavaScript application error message—the same message that appeared when their own site was temporarily unavailable. They therefore suspected that Googlebot had fetched an error or fallback screen instead of the actual content, leading it to treat different URLs as duplicates.
John Mueller, as quoted in the report, considered this a possible explanation but did not confirm the cause in this case. Another user shared a similar experience and said the issue resolved on its own after several weeks. That does not justify promising a recovery timeline or recommending that all sites simply wait.
Focus on what Google saw
Mueller recommended using Search Console’s live URL inspection to see how Google renders the page. This can help confirm whether errors are still appearing, but a normal result now does not prove that an error screen was never returned in the past.
According to his explanation, after fetching error content, Google may select the site’s own URL as canonical, treat the page as a soft 404, or select another URL as canonical. In any of these cases, the actual content may fail to appear properly in search results. These outcomes should not all be described as the same kind of “deindexing.”
Resolving the issue therefore requires looking beyond the canonical setting. If checks reveal server or rendering errors, fix those first. Then use automated pre-deployment tests and regular monitoring of important pages to reduce the likelihood of recurrence. These are troubleshooting and prevention recommendations from the report; they do not guarantee restoration to the index.
Cross-domain canonicals and indexing issues: perspectives from across the web
If a page really does have a canonical pointing to an unfamiliar domain, does that mean it has been hacked?
Not necessarily. The Search Engine Journal author considers hacking one possibility if a site actually contains a cross-domain canonical pointing to another site, but the tag alone cannot confirm a compromise. First, investigate the URL the page actually declares and where that setting came from. Google selecting an unfamiliar URL as canonical is not the same as the site itself including that tag.
How can past errors be incorporated into future testing?
Mueller's approach is to add a corresponding test whenever a problem is discovered and run it before deployment. You can also crawl important pages regularly, either yourself or through a third-party tool, to check for problems. He gave hourly checks as an example, but the frequency can be adjusted to suit the site. These measures can help detect errors early; they do not guarantee indexing recovery.
References
- Meta Tags for SEO: What They Are, Why They Matter, and How to Use Themneilpatel.com · 2026-09-04T16:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Google Responds To Cross-Domain Canonical De-Indexing Reportwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-09-18T11:39:51+00:00 — Discusses: If a page really does have a canonical pointing to an unfamiliar domain, does that mean it has been hacked?; How can past errors be incorporated into future testing?

