To identify crawl errors, cross-check data from server logs, Google Search Console, and site audit tools. Record the affected URLs, response statuses, and crawl activity. To prioritize fixes, first assess whether issues block search engine access and whether they affect the entire site or individual pages. Then consider how important those pages are to the business and what resources are available. Severity ratings from tools are useful for initial triage, but the total error count alone should not determine priorities.
Identify the affected URLs, then investigate what happened
Each of these three data sources serves a different purpose: Search Console helps you review issues reported by Google; site audit tools proactively scan your site and list problem pages with suggested fixes; server logs let you investigate crawl activity for individual URLs. Record not just the number of errors but also the details needed to investigate them.
- Affected URLs: Which pages have errors, and do they include important product pages?
- Response status: For example, a 404 means no page was found at the specified URL, possibly because content was deleted or the URL was misspelled.
- Historical records: Review changes in status codes over time and the most recent crawl date for individual URLs to help identify persistent issues or verify fixes.
To spot-check a single page, you can also inspect the HTTP status code of its HTML document in the network request log in your browser’s developer tools.
Distinguish single-page errors from sitewide problems
Sitewide access issues and individual URL errors should be assessed separately. A page returning a 404 does not mean search engines cannot crawl other pages normally. A 404 in a report is therefore not enough to conclude that search engines cannot crawl the entire site.
Next, consider the site’s goals. In a 2022 article, Semrush gives an example: if search engines frequently crawl a blog but overlook product pages that are more important to the business, adjusting internal links may be worth considering. This suggestion is based on how often different pages are crawled. It does not guarantee that changes will lead to indexing, nor does it mean every site should prioritize product pages.
Start with severity, then adjust priorities to suit the site
Semrush’s 2021 material classifies audit issues as errors, warnings, and notices. These categories can serve as an initial guide to prioritization:
- Address major issues that block access first: Especially those that hinder crawling or indexing.
- Then address more important warnings: Review the affected pages and schedule fixes in line with business goals.
- Leave minor notices until later: Plan improvements after the main obstacles have been addressed.
However, this is not an official order of priority prescribed by search engines. Screaming Frog’s 2022 guidance also emphasizes that you should not simply work through an issue list without considering the business, strategy, resources, and the site’s circumstances. For example, if logs show that an old URL you thought had been redirected is still being crawled frequently, check whether the redirect is correct rather than simply trying to reduce the error count in the report.
Handling crawl errors: perspectives from across the web
If a site has crawl errors on a particular day, does that mean the problem is ongoing?
Not necessarily. Forum users suggested that site downtime or hosting problems that day could cause crawl errors. These are only possible causes to investigate, not grounds for concluding that the hosting failed. Compare the timing of the errors with server logs and check whether subsequent status codes continue to indicate problems before deciding whether to investigate further or schedule fixes.
Should every URL returning a 404 be redirected?
Not every URL needs a redirect. A 404 means no page was found at the specified URL, possibly because the content was deleted or the URL was misspelled. If the link is incorrect, update it; if the page has moved or been removed, Semrush suggests that a 301 redirect may be appropriate. First establish what happened to the URL, then choose a suitable fix.
Can errors be left unaddressed if their number is below a certain threshold?
No single number should be treated as a universal threshold. One discussion suggests that a small number of crawl errors caused by strings containing slashes is not a concern, while millions would warrant modifying the strings. However, this is an opinion about a specific situation, not an official rule. Prioritization should still account for the nature of the problem, the site’s goals, and available resources, rather than relying solely on the total error count.
References
- Google - Insights - Customer Viewswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: If a site has crawl errors on a particular day, does that mean the problem is ongoing?
- What Are Crawl Errors & How Do They Affect SEO?www.semrush.com · 2021-06-10T16:30:00Z — Discusses: Should every URL returning a 404 be redirected?
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider Update – Version 17.0www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2022-08-17T07:33:58+00:00 — Discusses: Can errors be left unaddressed if their number is below a certain threshold?
- SEO - Crawl Errorswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can errors be left unaddressed if their number is below a certain threshold?
- What Is a Site Crawler? (How Do Site Crawlers Work?)www.semrush.com · 2021-06-11T15:55:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Advanced SEO Tasks when Working with Wixwww.semrush.com · 2022-09-23T01:40:00Z — Discusses: If a site has crawl errors on a particular day, does that mean the problem is ongoing?
- HTTP Status Codes Explained: Full List & Impact on SEOwww.semrush.com · 2021-03-22T15:00:00Z — Source used in the article above.



