Who should you recruit for content testing?

ProcrustesPR

For content testing, recruit people whose mindset, circumstances, and goals genuinely match those of the intended audience, not just people who can complete the steps. Recruitment criteria should reflect the testing goals: if you want to understand whether readers can comprehend and use the content, prioritize their background knowledge and real needs. For exploratory tasks that require in-depth reading, comparison, and research, the scenario should closely match participants’ current problems and emotional states. Simply asking them to pretend to be interested is not enough.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should I divide my DIY SEO budget?

Identify the intended audience before setting recruitment criteria

The effectiveness of content depends heavily on its intended audience. An article that suits one group of readers will not necessarily be valuable to everyone. When recruiting, go beyond asking whether someone is willing to participate: check whether they have the motivation and background needed to evaluate the content.

  • Mindset: Do they genuinely want to learn about the topic, rather than reading only to follow study instructions?
  • Circumstances: Are they currently facing the problem the content aims to help address?
  • Goals: Do the answers they want from the content align with those sought by the intended audience?
  • Background knowledge: Does their knowledge match the level expected of the intended readers? Do not default to recruiting only experts or beginners.

For example, when testing educational content about investing, recruit people who genuinely want to learn about investing. Randomly recruited participants may lack the background needed to understand an article about preferred and common stock. Their reading difficulties do not, on their own, show that the article is ineffective for its intended audience.

Exploratory tasks require genuine, current needs

Different tasks have different requirements for participants. For simple tasks with clear success or failure criteria, such as finding the name of a media contact, participants can sometimes follow instructions and complete the task even without a genuine need. Exploratory tasks, however, require readers to engage in reading and research, so completing the steps alone is not enough to determine whether the right people were recruited.

When testing involves extensive reading and research, tasks should correspond to problems participants need to solve in real life. The research guidance suggests that better test results are more likely when participants become absorbed in the activity and temporarily forget they are being tested. This requires more than writing realistic task descriptions: participants’ current circumstances and emotional states also need to match the scenario.

Do not recruit arbitrary stand-ins for medical and technical content

Information about illnesses illustrates why participant selection matters. For patient-facing cancer information, people with a cancer diagnosis generally fit the intended audience better than people asked to pretend they care about the illness. Their emotional involvement differs, and they may already have gained relevant knowledge from their doctors or their own research. If the content is written for healthcare professionals, recruitment criteria for patients cannot simply be applied.

Primary caregivers may also be suitable participants, provided they are highly involved in care, rather than merely acquainted with the patient. Using an article about adult non-Hodgkin lymphoma as an example, the source recommends recruiting people diagnosed with the condition or their primary caregivers. Scientific and technical content requires similar care: stand-ins cannot quickly acquire the necessary background knowledge and understanding of the target readers’ circumstances, so they may not be able to assess the content’s value appropriately.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow do I write SEO articles that help my business?

Participants for content testing: perspectives from across the web

If you cannot find target readers, can you ask other people to put themselves in their shoes?

Stand-ins should not be treated as equivalent substitutes for target readers. Evaluating content requires an understanding of readers’ real circumstances and existing knowledge, which proxy participants cannot immediately acquire. This is especially true of scientific or technical content. If stand-ins are used for testing, their reactions cannot be taken directly as the target audience’s assessment of the content’s value.

Can you recruit caregivers to test patient information?

You can consider recruiting primary caregivers, provided they are highly involved in care, rather than merely acquainted with the patient. For information about adult non-Hodgkin lymphoma, for example, the source recommends recruiting people diagnosed with the condition or their primary caregivers. Patients and caregivers may still have different circumstances, so their reactions should not be assumed to be identical.

Are the participant requirements the same for simple lookup tasks and exploratory tasks?

Not entirely. Participants can sometimes complete simple pass-or-fail tasks even without a genuine need. Exploratory tasks depend more heavily on participants’ current circumstances and emotional states matching the scenario. If the aim is to understand how readers engage with content while researching, task completion alone should not determine whether a participant is suitable.

ProcrustesPRDo SEO articles have to be long?

References

  1. How to Test Content with Userswww.nngroup.com · 2021-02-07T17:00:00+0000 — Discusses: If you cannot find target readers, can you ask other people to put themselves in their shoes?; Can you recruit caregivers to test patient information?

Related articles

How should I divide my DIY SEO budget?How do I write SEO articles that help my business?Do SEO articles have to be long?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: Website contentAI Makes Marketing Harder. Don’t Expect an Easy Ride.What Is Content Marketing? Turning Helpful Content into Business ResultsWhat Is Integrated Marketing? Connecting Content, Search, Social Media, and EmailHow Do B2B Companies Use Blogs and Content Management Systems?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR