Use in-page tabs to switch between related content on the same page, and navigation tabs to move to different pages or broader content categories. Consider accordions when readers only need a few sections and want to expand content themselves. If readers need to read everything from start to finish or compare several pieces of information at once, displaying the content directly is often more appropriate. The key is not which component saves the most space, but what readers need to accomplish.
First, distinguish between switching content and leaving the page
In a 2024 article, NN/g’s Evan Sunwall distinguishes between two types of tabs. In-page tabs switch between related, similar content on the same page, generally keeping the same layout while displaying different data. Navigation tabs take users to other pages, which can cover broader topics and do not need to contain similar content.
- In-page tabs: For example, the financial charts in Sunwall’s article remain line charts when users switch market categories or time scales, and users stay on the same page. One tab should be selected by default, and users expect content to appear immediately when they switch tabs.
- Navigation tabs: Users expect to open a new page and may therefore accept a brief loading time. Usually, one tab is selected. However, no tab needs to be selected if users arrive through another entry point at a page that does not belong to any tab.
Do not mix these two behaviors within the same set of controls. For example, if most tabs only switch between career-related information but one leads to a homepage without tabs, the behavior becomes difficult to predict. If an interface needs both types of tabs, distinguish them visually.
Accordions suit selective reading, not expanding every section in turn
When an accordion is collapsed, its section headings provide an overview of the content; readers see the details only after expanding it. According to NN/g’s design guidance from 2014 and 2017, accordions suit situations where readers need to find only a few key items, such as in FAQs, tables of contents, or indexes. They should not be used merely to make a long page look shorter by hiding content.
The 2024 article on tabs also notes that accordions are particularly suitable for mobile interfaces with limited space, as they accommodate longer labels and short pieces of content. Tabs on desktop interfaces are better suited to lengthy content and complex layouts. The choice depends on the context; this does not mean every mobile page should use accordions.
For accordions, the 2014 article recommends allowing multiple sections to remain open at once and preserving each section’s expanded or collapsed state until users change it themselves. This prevents content they have just opened from closing again.
For reading in full or comparing information, first consider showing content directly
If content needs to be read sequentially, like an article or a book chapter, repeatedly expanding accordions adds extra steps. Amy Schade noted in 2017 that in-page links merely assist navigation: readers can scroll through the full text without clicking them. Accordions, however, require interaction to reveal content, making hidden information easier to overlook. In-page links are not in-page tabs; the two should not be confused.
Tabs have a similar limitation: if readers need to compare information across different panels at the same time, switching back and forth gives them more to remember and more actions to take. In that situation, displaying the information together on the same page serves readers better than simply aiming for a cleaner layout.
In-page tabs, navigation tabs, and accordions: perspectives from across the web
Which is easier to navigate: accordions or a table of contents with in-page links?
It depends on where the table of contents appears and how readers move through the content. If a table of contents with in-page links appears only at the top of the page and does not stay fixed in place, readers may need to return to the top to jump to another section. With accordions, other sections may be visible at the top or bottom of the expanded content. On the other hand, in-page links do not hide the main text, so readers can simply scroll through it. Other design guidance notes that without cues, in-page links may leave users unsure of their location if they expected a new page to open.
Should a very long page be collapsed into accordions?
Not necessarily. The guidance suggests considering other navigation approaches for an extremely long page, such as dividing it into several more manageable pages rather than relying solely on accordions to collapse the content. Splitting pages should not go to the opposite extreme of breaking content into numerous very short pages, either. Before deciding, assess the target audience’s common and critical use cases, then choose an appropriate way to organize the content.
Where are tab controls most likely to be noticed?
The design guidance recommends placing the tab list above the content panel and making the panel associated with in-page tabs clearly visible. Users may overlook vertically arranged tab lists or those placed at the bottom. An unclear relationship between the controls and the panel can also make the interface harder to understand. This is guidance on presenting tabs, not a substitute for assessing actual use cases.
Does placing content inside accordions or tabs affect search visibility or AI citations?
There is no single answer. A 2022 article suggests that Google appears to crawl and index this kind of hidden content, but says it is unclear whether content in tabs is given less weight. A separate 2026 article recommends keeping important information visible, clearly structured, and crawlable if the goal is for AI to cite it, rather than hiding it behind interactive components. These are the authors’ assessments and recommendations, not guarantees about current platform rules.
References
- Do Minimalist Website Designs Help or Hurt Your SEO?neilpatel.com · 2022-11-14T08:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Does placing content inside accordions or tabs affect search visibility or AI citations?
- Anchors OK? Re-Assessing In-Page Linkswww.nngroup.com · 2017-05-07T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Which is easier to navigate: accordions or a table of contents with in-page links?
- The June 2026 SEO Update by Yoast recapyoast.com · 2026-07-01T15:02:35+00:00 — Discusses: Does placing content inside accordions or tabs affect search visibility or AI citations?
- Tabs, Used Rightwww.nngroup.com · 2024-08-02T17:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Where are tab controls most likely to be noticed?
- Accordions Are Not Always the Answer for Complex Content on Desktopswww.nngroup.com · 2014-05-18T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Which is easier to navigate: accordions or a table of contents with in-page links?; Should a very long page be collapsed into accordions?



