Deleting content may lower search rankings and reduce traffic, but you cannot predict the loss simply by counting the words removed. Nor can you assume that deleting low-quality pages will improve rankings. In a two-page test conducted by Ahrefs in 2023, most rankings dropped only a few positions, yet traffic still suffered. Traffic recovered after the content was restored. When assessing your own site, first distinguish between deleting some text, removing the main content, and deleting an entire page. Then consider the page’s existing rankings, traffic, and links.
Still ranking after content removal does not mean nothing was lost
In a test published in 2023, Ahrefs author Patrick Stox selected two articles, “Top Bing Searches” and “Top YouTube Searches.” On August 8, he removed their main content, leaving only the titles and author bios, and restored it on August 20.
- Traffic declined while the content was removed and recovered after it was restored.
- Rankings for many search terms dropped only a few positions, and the pages still ranked relatively well.
- The YouTube article lost more traffic, showing that the size of a ranking change alone is not enough to assess traffic loss.
This was only a short-term observation of two pages that already ranked. It cannot predict results for all websites, nor does it directly answer what would happen if only a single passage were deleted. The author explicitly advises against repeating the experiment and warns that other websites may see different results.
Before deleting a page, consider how it helps people find your site and where it links
An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange notes that if search engines had not already filtered the pages out of search results or devalued them, deleting those pages could leave fewer opportunities for people to find the site through search. It could also reduce links pointing to important pages.
The same answer speculates that if the pages had already been filtered out or devalued because of duplicate content, deleting them might have a limited direct effect on other pages. Even if links to poor-quality pages were reduced, the benefit might not be noticeable. These are judgments made under specific conditions in a community answer, not statements of Google’s current rules. They do not support the conclusion that deleting more pages leads to better rankings.
An expected improvement timeline is not a measured result
One questioner deleted product pages copied from manufacturers, used the 410 status code, and hoped rankings would improve within four to six weeks. They later clarified that the products were not being sold and that the pages were almost useless. But these were only the questioner’s expectations and assessments. There were no follow-up data showing improved rankings, so this example cannot support promises about when rankings will recover or improve.
Why the pages still ranked after content removal remains uncertain
The Ahrefs author could not determine whether links were sustaining rankings after the main content was removed or whether Google was still using the old content. His earlier robots.txt test only blocked crawling, and he acknowledged that he could not be sure it measured the effects of content removal. These results therefore do not prove that content is unimportant. To assess the effects of removing content from a specific page, you still need to establish what will be removed and review the page’s existing search performance and links. The available information does not establish a percentage loss that applies to all websites.
Deleting page content and its effects on search rankings and traffic: perspectives from across the web
Does deleting content have the same effect as disavowing backlinks?
You cannot assume the effects are the same. After comparing two of his own tests, the Ahrefs author said that disavowing all links to these two articles, including high-quality links, produced results quite similar to removing their main content: rankings dropped only a few positions in both cases. However, this was only a comparison of tests on specific existing pages. It does not prove that the two actions work through the same mechanisms, nor can it predict results for other pages.
References
- Deleted duplicate pages will search engine ratings improve?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- I Deleted the Content From Two Posts To See if They’d Still Rank. Here’s What Happenedahrefs.com · 2023-10-26T17:03:08+00:00 — Discusses: Does deleting content have the same effect as disavowing backlinks?
- Deleted duplicate pages will search engine ratings improve?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- Deleted duplicate pages will search engine ratings improve?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- The Story of Blocking 2 High-Ranking Pages With Robots.txtahrefs.com · 2023-07-10T02:11:55+00:00 — Source used in the article above.



