Regularly pruning existing content reduces outdated, duplicate, and contradictory information so that what remains still answers readers’ questions and supports current business needs. Decisions should not be based solely on publication dates or traffic. Instead, first identify what must be kept, then decide whether to retain each item as is, consolidate and update it, or remove it. This is not about publishing fewer articles or conducting a one-time mass purge. It is ongoing maintenance that requires assigned owners and regular discussions.
Adding content without maintaining it leaves old problems in place
The Content Marketing Institute article calls the accumulated costs of failing to maintain, update, or remove content “content debt.” For example, buyers may find outdated pricing or read contradictory statements on different pages. Even if a new article is accurate, old answers may remain on the website.
Publishing less therefore cannot replace maintenance. The author argues that pruning is not about making the content library as small as possible, but about removing content that no longer appropriately represents the brand and making what remains more valuable. Teams that prioritize extensive testing can retire ineffective content after testing; teams that prioritize quality should also ask whether new work genuinely adds value to their existing content.
At Procrustes, we turn the questions customers genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates rather than a focus solely on publishing new articles.
Identify what must stay before deciding what to cut
Before deleting anything, take stock of outdated information, duplicate material, and contradictory statements. Then ask of each item: “What business outcome does it help achieve now?” Under the criteria proposed in the article, core content may support sales conversations or renewals, generate genuine business opportunities through search rankings, or support promises the brand still fulfills.
- Keep as is: The content remains accurate and has a clear current purpose.
- Consolidate and update: The topic remains valuable, but the information needs correcting or overlaps with other material.
- Remove: The content is no longer relevant, is inaccurate, or is no longer appropriate to represent the brand.
Traffic alone does not mean content must stay. Also ask who is reading it, why they are visiting, and whether you would still publish the same content today. In most of the client content libraries the author reviewed, core material accounted for roughly one-tenth of the total. However, this reflects the author’s experience working with clients; it is not a rule that every website should delete 90% of its content.
Make pruning a routine of small batches and open discussion
The article recommends discussing a small batch of material weekly or every other week, assigning an owner, and optionally asking someone to argue against keeping it. Having junior team members offer their assessments before senior colleagues is another exercise the author suggests: the team must explain what makes content good, rather than deciding what stays based solely on seniority.
When adding material, teams can also adopt the author’s proposed “one-in” approach: identify which existing item the new content will replace or retire, or which item it will be combined with. This is a management recommendation to prevent the content library from expanding unchecked, not a platform requirement.
Removal does not mean permanent deletion, and evergreen content still needs review
In practice, the author recommends archiving content rather than deleting it outright, while handling redirects and basic SEO maintenance. Compliance and legal pages are exempt from pruning. Truly evergreen content should be checked again for accuracy, not taken down simply because it is old. When reviewing a pruning checklist, assess separately whether the content still has value and whether its information remains accurate. Do not apply a blanket cutoff based on dates alone.
Content pruning: perspectives from across the web
Can AI help identify which text to cut?
Yes, but AI’s suggestions should only be a starting point for tightening a draft. You can ask AI to identify passages that may be off-topic, repetitive, or lacking in value, as well as words and phrases that could be omitted. The Screaming Frog article suggests that lengthy or off-topic text may distract readers from the question they came to resolve. Editors still need to review AI’s suggestions in light of readers’ needs and verify the information, rather than treating AI’s judgment as sufficient grounds for deletion.
Why can discussing what to cut build editorial judgment?
Deciding whether existing material should stay requires articulating what counts as good content and whether it still deserves a place. The Content Marketing Institute author argues that teams build judgment through repeatedly explaining their reasoning, opening it to discussion, and taking responsibility for the consequences of their decisions. For example, material that already attracts traffic need not be retained automatically. Teams can also ask who the visitors are, why they come, and whether they would still publish the same content today.
References
- Why Your Best Content Strategy Is Subtractioncontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Why can discussing what to cut build editorial judgment?
- I’m a copywriting expert. Steal my ChatGPT prompts.www.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2024-01-04T14:13:03+00:00 — Discusses: Can AI help identify which text to cut?




