To evaluate content and image quality, first ask whether they serve the page’s purpose and meet readers’ needs. Then check whether the text is easy to understand, the images help explain the content, and the images’ technical settings are appropriate. This article focuses on website content and SEO: review text page by page against search intent, and assess whether images fit the content, guide readers, and use optimized files. Technical settings alone should not determine quality.
First, identify the need the page should meet
In its 2023 article on enterprise SEO audits, Semrush recommends first listing important pages, such as those that generate more conversions or organic traffic, and then manually analyzing each one. Evaluation priorities vary with search intent, so before comparing quality, establish what readers are looking for when they visit the page.
- Meeting readers’ needs: Does the content match the search intent behind the target keywords?
- Areas to improve: Compared with competitors that rank higher for the primary keyword, which parts of the content could be improved?
- Page elements working together: Do the title, summary, images, and internal links all support the page’s purpose?
The aim is to find opportunities for improvement, not to treat competitors’ rankings as direct quality scores. These recommendations emphasize in-depth manual review but do not provide a universal passing standard for all articles.
As part of our content services at Procrustes, we turn the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.
Review the text: Where might readers feel confused or unconvinced?
Alongside checking search intent, review each paragraph for readability. In a discussion published by Animalz in 2025, an interviewee described asking Lex for examples and analogies while drafting, as well as for places where readers might be confused or disagree. They used four types of questions to identify potential revisions:
- Which parts are particularly good and worth keeping?
- Which parts are boring and might cause readers to lose interest?
- Which parts are difficult to understand and need clarification?
- Which claims might readers find unconvincing or disagree with?
This is an interviewee’s experience of using AI to help revise content, not a certification of quality. The interviewee also said they accepted only some of the feedback. These questions can help identify passages that need review, but an AI response calling a claim “correct” does not mean the facts have been verified.
Review images: Assess purpose and technical factors separately
A 2024 article on Neil Patel’s website recommends original, high-quality images that guide readers through the content, with the choice of images reflecting readers’ needs for that type of content. For example, infographics may make information easier to absorb, while JPEG may be worth considering for e-commerce images. These are examples of possible uses, not a requirement that every product image use the same format.
On the technical side, Semrush’s checklist includes descriptive filenames, alt text, file compression, and web-friendly formats such as JPEG or WebP. The article also recommends including the primary keyword in alt text. This is that article’s SEO advice; it is not presented here as a current platform rule.
In practice, first manually check whether images on important pages fit the content, then use tools to identify where other images need optimization. If a website has many images, automated checks can help compile a list of issues. However, tools identify technical improvements; whether an image genuinely helps readers understand the content still needs to be judged against the page’s purpose.
Content and image quality: perspectives from across the web
Is an article necessarily low quality if it is only 300–500 words long?
You cannot draw that conclusion from word count alone. One post on Warrior Forum criticized low-quality content of 300–500 words, but it also pointed to problems such as similarity to other articles online and poor design. This was an individual contributor's criticism, not a universal word-count threshold. Evaluation should still focus on the page's purpose and whether the content matches readers' search intent.
If AI identifies a problem in an article, does that mean it must be revised?
Not necessarily. While drafting, you can ask AI to flag passages that readers might find confusing, disagree with, or find unconvincing. Use this feedback to help decide what to revise. In the discussion published by Animalz, however, the participant said they accepted only some of the feedback. When factual accuracy is at issue, an AI response is not verification; the facts still need to be checked separately.
If a website has too many images, should every image be checked manually?
You do not have to rely entirely on checking every image manually. For websites with many images, Semrush recommends using tools to automatically identify where images or alt text need optimization, then making a plan to address those issues. This can narrow the scope of manual technical checks. However, you still need to assess images within the page to judge whether they guide readers and meet their needs for that type of content.
References
- Your SEO is doomed!!!www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Is an article necessarily low quality if it is only 300–500 words long?
- Enterprise SEO Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide for Site Ownerswww.semrush.com · 2023-11-14T09:55:00Z — Discusses: Is an article necessarily low quality if it is only 300–500 words long?; If a website has too many images, should every image be checked manually?
- AI as a Personal Trainer for Writers: A Conversation with Nathan Baschez of Lexwww.animalz.co · 2025-03-04T00:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: If AI identifies a problem in an article, does that mean it must be revised?
- Image SEO: Tips for Image Optimizationneilpatel.com · 2024-11-26T20:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: If a website has too many images, should every image be checked manually?

