Strong ideas are essential to content ideation because writing and presentation cannot replace the value of the content itself. Articles from Screaming Frog and Animalz emphasize a shared principle: develop the idea first, then decide how to write and present it. To assess an idea’s quality, start by asking whether it goes beyond overused topics and whether it is worth developing further. If the goal is to earn external links, also ask why readers would need to visit the page. These are practical content marketing recommendations, not a claim that good ideas necessarily deliver results.
Format can showcase an idea, but it cannot replace the value of the content
In a 2018 article, Screaming Frog looked back at how infographics once attracted coverage and links more easily thanks to their novel format and attractive design. The author argued that repeatedly using formats that once worked leads to diminishing returns. This was a practical observation from a particular period, not a universal rule about the effectiveness of all content formats today.
The article did not dismiss infographics. Instead, it noted that great ideas can still be presented through infographics or other formats. Rather than starting with “let’s make a graphic,” ask “what makes this idea worth presenting?” New packaging alone does not make content original.
To earn links, give readers a reason to visit the page
A 2019 Screaming Frog article argued that you should plan material worth linking to early in ideation, rather than wait until the content is finished to figure out how to ask others for links. It offered these questions to consider:
- Does the page provide additional data to explore?
- Does an interactive presentation make the data easier to view, sort, and filter?
- Can someone citing the page clearly explain what readers will gain by visiting it?
For example, an interactive page that lets readers filter data offers more than a change in appearance: it gives them a reason to explore further. These criteria apply to content intended to earn links. They are not the sole quality standard for every article, nor do they guarantee that anyone will cite the content.
Good ideas take time—collect them before you need to write
In a 2021 article, Nathan Wahl of Animalz emphasized that ideas need time to develop and that even great writing cannot conceal a weak idea. He recommended keeping initial thoughts in one document: notes from sales conversations, unexpected customer feedback, colleagues’ remarks, or excerpts from reading. These can be developed later.
Another approach is to collect examples of content you like that has performed well. In 2018, Screaming Frog recommended keeping an inspiration file that is visual and easy to browse, so you can revisit it when you get stuck. Collecting initial thoughts saves ideas that are not yet fully formed; collecting examples gives you work to learn from. Both build a store of material for ideation, so you do not have to start from a blank page every time.
At Procrustes, our content services turn questions that genuinely matter to clients into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
Tools can help generate ideas, but the results still need evaluation
A 2023 Screaming Frog article described how AI could help explore topics and find insights worth pursuing. However, the author found that asking AI directly for campaign concepts tended to produce the same old ideas repeatedly. This was an observation about usage at the time, not grounds for assuming that all current models have the same limitations. Tool-generated concepts are still only a starting point. To develop them further, assess whether the content offers something original and provides material worth exploring.
Idea quality in content ideation: perspectives from across the web
Does support from credible sources mean an idea is good enough?
Not necessarily. Research can help you find well-supported ideas, but you still need to assess whether it is relevant to the topic being discussed and whether the idea itself is worth developing. In 2018, Screaming Frog recommended looking to research for inspiration. Source credibility is a factor to consider, not a substitute for judging an idea’s quality.
Do you have to create large-scale interactive content to earn links?
Not necessarily. In 2018, Screaming Frog argued that content designed to earn links needs to be outstanding, unique, and visually appealing, which often involves larger-scale interactive pieces. This was the author’s observation about practice, not a requirement that every idea take an interactive form. Another article also argued that great ideas can be presented through infographics or other formats.
Can you treat a headline from an idea generator as a good idea straight away?
You should not assume so. In 2018, Screaming Frog suggested that content idea generators can provide headlines early in ideation to get your thinking started, but their results should be treated with caution. A headline can suggest an angle without the underlying idea being fully developed. You still need to allow time to develop it, rather than expecting polished writing to conceal a weak idea.
References
- 27 Real Life and Ethical Use Cases for AI in Digital PRwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2023-07-11T13:00:31+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- The Content Writing Guide: How to Write Blog Posts That Readers Care About in the Age of AIwww.animalz.co · 2021-07-05T00:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Does support from credible sources mean an idea is good enough?; Can you treat a headline from an idea generator as a good idea straight away?
- Interactive Content Launch Checklist – 12 Things to Do Before You Send It to the Clientwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2018-05-14T14:01:58+00:00 — Discusses: Do you have to create large-scale interactive content to earn links?
- Content Ideation: Tools & Techniqueswww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2018-03-20T14:06:29+00:00 — Discusses: Does support from credible sources mean an idea is good enough?; Do you have to create large-scale interactive content to earn links?
- The Do’s and Don’ts of Chasing for a Linkwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2019-08-15T11:30:38+00:00 — Source used in the article above.


