A content audit should assess not only article quality but also whether readers can find, open, and use the content easily. Start by checking whether important pages open, whether navigation and images work properly, and how pages perform in terms of loading speed, responsiveness, and layout stability. Then use performance data to identify problems. Speed, however, cannot replace content quality. The sources cited here also do not establish the current Core Web Vitals metrics and thresholds, so historical values should not be treated as today’s standards.
First, check whether content can be found and used
Semrush’s 2023 technical SEO article states that important pages should be accessible to both people and search engines, and that a clear, useful site structure helps them find and understand content. An audit should therefore go beyond the text to check whether readers can reach the page and read its content:
- Navigation and structure: Is important content easy to find, or is it buried under confusing categories?
- Links and images: Are internal links broken? Are broken images interfering with reading?
- Loading and mobile experience: Do pages load slowly? Are they suitable for use on mobile devices?
For example, even if an article is comprehensive, a broken link leading to it is still a user experience issue that needs attention. Editing only the title and body will not help readers reach the page.
At Procrustes, our work includes not only content planning, writing, and updates, but also page planning, design, and functionality development for the websites we build through client partnerships.
Separate real-user data from recommendations when assessing speed
Screaming Frog’s 2021 article recommends including Core Web Vitals in content audits alongside SEO and user behavior data. It describes the Chrome User Experience Report as collecting real-user data that can be viewed through tools such as Search Console and PageSpeed Insights. The article outlines the following uses:
- Reviewing site-wide issues: Use Search Console’s Core Web Vitals feature.
- Analyzing individual pages: Use PageSpeed Insights to analyze mobile and desktop performance and identify opportunities for improvement.
- Interpreting data: Field data from the Chrome User Experience Report reflects users’ experiences and should be considered separately from the tools’ recommendations for improvement.
These descriptions reflect the tools’ uses at the time of the article; they do not verify their current interfaces or functionality. When compiling audit findings, record both “which pages have problems” and “where improvements can be made,” rather than just a single score.
Use historical thresholds as background and address specific problems
The 2021 article listed LCP, FID, and CLS as metrics relating to the display of the main content, responsiveness to interaction, and layout shifts, respectively. Its recommended thresholds at the time were LCP below 2.5 seconds, FID no greater than 100 milliseconds, and CLS no greater than 0.1. These are historical figures, not current standards for passing.
Which problems to fix first also depends on the nature of each issue. Semrush’s site audit material identifies issues labeled “Errors” in its tool, such as broken internal links, as the most urgent. This guidance is based on that tool’s categories, not an official priority order for all websites.
When addressing speed issues, continue checking whether the content meets readers’ needs. No matter how fast a website is, speed cannot compensate for low-quality content that fails to meet those needs, nor can it guarantee improved rankings.
Website experience and speed: perspectives from across the web
Should an ecommerce content audit assess the checkout experience?
If the content is intended in part to guide readers toward a purchase, the checkout experience can be included in the review. Semrush's 2018 article lists a good ecommerce checkout experience as one example of how a website can effectively provide a solution. This recommendation applies to websites with a purchasing process; it does not mean that the checkout experience must be checked for every content page, nor should it be treated as a current search ranking rule.
Can you compare your pages' speed with competitors' pages?
Yes. Comparing competitors' pages can help you identify opportunities to improve your own site. Screaming Frog's 2021 article described using the Chrome Web Vitals Extension to view metrics while browsing and to compare competitors' pages. However, that historical article cannot confirm the extension's current status or functionality, so check these before using it.
What technical elements can you check after finding that a page loads slowly?
You can examine the page's code and file sizes for opportunities to optimize them. Semrush's technical SEO article lists optimizing code and file sizes as common tasks for speeding up page loading. This provides a direction for further investigation, but it does not establish that every slow page has the same cause; each page still needs to be analyzed individually.
References
- 12 Benefits of SEO for Your Business: From Traffic to AI Visibilitywww.semrush.com · 2023-12-06T17:09:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Conducting an SEO Content Audit: 6 Things You Might Be Overlookingwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2021-11-15T13:37:48+00:00 — Discusses: Can you compare your pages' speed with competitors' pages?
- The Future of SEO: Understanding, Credibility, & Deliverabilitywww.semrush.com · 2018-02-05T08:00:00Z — Discusses: Should an ecommerce content audit assess the checkout experience?
- Types of SEO: What Does Your Site Need to Succeed?www.semrush.com · 2023-01-04T15:38:00Z — Discusses: What technical elements can you check after finding that a page loads slowly?

