Why Do Consumers Hesitate to Click Links?

ProcrustesPR

Consumers may hesitate to click links for reasons other than a URL’s length or use of a shortener. Respondents in a Bitly survey cited security concerns, links that looked like clickbait, unclear descriptions of where links led, and a mismatch between shared content and the link destination. But the reasons for hesitation depend on where a link appears and how it is used: URLs in social posts, product search results, and call-to-action buttons on shopping pages require different explanations. Survey responses should not be treated as actual click-through rates, either.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDo we still need SEO now that AI answers questions?

Check security concerns and link destinations before focusing on URL format

Search Engine Journal reported on this Bitly survey in October 2026. Conducted from July 27 to August 5 that year, the survey covered 1,006 U.S. consumers and 501 U.S. marketers and creators. The following percentages reflect the consumers surveyed and should not be assumed to represent all consumers.

  • 57% mentioned concerns about URL security.
  • 52% said they would hesitate if a link looked like clickbait.
  • 44% were concerned about unclear descriptions of where links led.
  • 42% were concerned about a mismatch between a creator’s usual content and the link destination.

These responses remind content publishers to look beyond a URL’s appearance when reviewing links. They should also check whether the accompanying text explains where the link leads and whether the destination meets the expectations set by the content. However, the survey does not prove that rewriting the text will necessarily increase clicks.

Brand recognition helps, but short URLs alone are not enough

In the same survey, 23% of consumers said generic short URLs that hide the brand name made them hesitate, while 28% were bothered by long URLs full of tracking parameters. The report noted that this five-percentage-point difference was within the survey’s margin of error, so it cannot establish that long URLs are more off-putting.

In addition, 48% said custom branded short URLs made them comfortable clicking because they could recognize the brand. Another 44% mentioned trust in the brand or creator sharing the link, and 43% mentioned text that clearly explained where the link led. When reviewing links, it therefore makes sense to check whether the brand is recognizable and the destination is clearly described. But switching to branded short URLs should not be assumed to eliminate other concerns. The survey was conducted by link management provider Bitly, whose commercial interests should also be considered.

Product images and shopping buttons serve different contexts

A discussion on Webmasters Stack Exchange suggested that product images might encourage clicks by helping users confirm that a product meets their needs. This is an experience-based judgment about product searches, not an experimental finding that applies to every link. It also cannot establish that images dispel security concerns.

For users who have already reached a shopping page and want to buy but remain hesitant, a 2018 article by awoo recommended testing design elements such as the color and font of call-to-action (CTA) buttons. This was conversion optimization advice at the time, not a current platform rule or a guarantee of increased clicks. First, distinguish whether users are worried about where a link leads, checking whether a product meets their needs, or hesitating over the next step. This helps avoid blaming URL format for different problems.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhy is AI not mentioning my brand?

Consumer hesitation to click links: perspectives from across the web

Does a shortened URL necessarily make people more hesitant than a long URL with tracking parameters?

That cannot be assumed. In the Bitly survey, 28% of respondents were bothered by long URLs full of tracking parameters, while 23% hesitated because generic short URLs hid the brand name. The report noted that the difference was within the survey’s margin of error. These are self-reported concerns and cannot establish which URL type has a higher actual click-through rate.

Can branded short URLs replace trust in the person or organization sharing a link and an explanation of its destination?

The survey does not establish that branded short URLs can replace trust in whoever shares a link or a clear explanation of where it leads. In the Bitly survey, more respondents said custom branded short URLs made them comfortable clicking because they could recognize the brand. But respondents also valued a trustworthy source and text that clearly explained the destination. Conducted by a link management provider, the survey can inform reviews of how links are presented, but it cannot guarantee that changing a URL will eliminate concerns.

Should product images and call-to-action buttons be approached in the same way to reduce hesitation to click?

No single approach suits both. Images in product search results may help users confirm whether a product meets their needs. For users who have reached a shopping page and want to buy but remain hesitant, testing the color or font of call-to-action buttons may be an option. The suggestion about images is an experience-based judgment from a discussion, while the button design advice dates to 2018. Neither is a current platform rule, and neither is guaranteed to work.

ProcrustesPRDoes every brand really need to rush into GEO in 2026?

References

  1. Google Shopping: beyond the basics, how can I optimize for high placement?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Should product images and call-to-action buttons be approached in the same way to reduce hesitation to click?
  2. 79% Of Consumers Quit Social Links That Land On A Homepage – Bitly Datawww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-28T19:00:59+00:00 — Discusses: Does a shortened URL necessarily make people more hesitant than a long URL with tracking parameters?; Can branded short URLs replace trust in the person or organization sharing a link and an explanation of its destination?
  3. 提高網站「轉換率」,你必知的4件事www.awoo.ai · 2018-11-06T03:04:33+00:00 — Discusses: Should product images and call-to-action buttons be approached in the same way to reduce hesitation to click?

Related articles

Do we still need SEO now that AI answers questions?Why is AI not mentioning my brand?Does every brand really need to rush into GEO in 2026?How do you get AI to mention your brand? The key factors in GEOWithout Clear Website Goals, You Could Be Working Toward the Wrong ResultsCan AI Replace a Social Media Manager?What Ten Years of SEO Taught Me About Its Real PurposeAI Makes Marketing Harder. Don’t Expect an Easy Ride.
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR