When do comments have SEO value?

ProcrustesPR

Comments are more likely to have SEO value when they expand on a page’s topic, provide relevant, high-quality content, and express questions in readers’ own words. But more comments do not necessarily mean better rankings. The answers in the Stack Exchange discussion support treating comments as part of a page’s content, though they differ on the criteria for judging their value. They also provide no quantitative evidence of ranking improvements. The focus should therefore be on what comments add and whether the comment section can stay on topic over time, rather than engagement alone.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRAre low-volume keywords still worth targeting?

The value lies in additional substance, not just more text

One contributor argues that comments add text and introduce users’ phrasing and vocabulary, which may help Google understand the topic and broaden the range of search terms the page covers. This contributor has observed Google finding query terms in comments and using them to generate search snippets.

This observation shows that comment text may be used in search results. A comment’s appearance in a snippet, however, does not establish that it improved rankings. When interpreting such observations, distinguish between content being used and rankings improving.

  • Addressing relevant questions that the original article has not covered better reflects the discussion’s emphasis on relevance than simply adding words.
  • Readers’ natural questions may introduce expressions the author did not use; this is different from deliberately stuffing in keywords.

There is agreement on relevance and quality, but views differ on keyword requirements

Another contributor takes a stricter position: comments do not automatically have SEO value. In this view, they help only if they are high-quality, relevant, and include the keywords the page aims to rank for. The first contributor, by contrast, places greater emphasis on the potential value of additional text and users’ vocabulary. Both focus on content, but the stricter conditions remain one contributor’s judgment, not official search engine rules.

For example, on an article about coffee grind size, “Why does the coffee taste bitter after I grind it finer?” is a specific question related to the article’s topic. “Great article” does not provide the same level of information about that topic. This is a hypothetical example illustrating differences in content, not a ranking test. Nor does it mean every comment must deliberately include specified terms.

Allowing comments also means taking on ongoing moderation

A further contributor treats visitors as content authors and argues for ongoing, proactive comment moderation. This contributor is especially concerned about whether comments stay relevant to the main article, even considering off-topic comments a greater concern than spam. The answer also advises watching for links to unrelated websites. This is the contributor’s risk assessment, however, not an empirically established comparison of which risks are greater.

  • Check whether comments remain focused on the main article, rather than keeping them simply because someone has replied.
  • Identify advertising, spam, and unrelated links to keep the comment section from drifting away from its original topic.
  • Assess whether ongoing maintenance is feasible, rather than moderating only once at launch.
ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow do I write SEO articles that help my business?

When comments have SEO value: perspectives from across the web

Does a comment appearing in a search snippet mean it improved rankings?

Not necessarily. One contributor notes that Google sometimes finds query terms in comments and uses them to generate search snippets. This shows that the comment text was used, but it does not prove that the comment improved the page’s ranking. The discussion provides no quantitative evidence of ranking changes, so appearing in a snippet and improving rankings should be assessed separately.

Do comments have to include the keywords you want to rank for to be valuable?

The contributors disagree on whether target keywords are necessary. One takes a stricter position, arguing that comments must be high-quality, relevant, and include the keywords the page aims to rank for to be helpful. Another places greater emphasis on the potential value of additional text and users’ natural language. Requiring target keywords is the contributor’s judgment, not an official search engine rule.

Besides spam, what should you consider when deciding whether to keep a comment section?

Check whether comments are relevant to the main article and whether they contain links to unrelated websites. One contributor treats visitors as content authors too and therefore advocates ongoing, proactive comment moderation. This contributor is especially concerned about comments going off topic, but that is a personal risk assessment, not an empirically established comparison of which risks are greater.

ProcrustesPRIs SEO suitable for my industry?

References

  1. Is it positive or negative for the average website to allow search engines to index user comments?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Besides spam, what should you consider when deciding whether to keep a comment section?
  2. Facebook Comments and page SEOwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Does a comment appearing in a search snippet mean it improved rankings?; Do comments have to include the keywords you want to rank for to be valuable?
  3. Facebook Comments and page SEOwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Do comments have to include the keywords you want to rank for to be valuable?

Related articles

Are low-volume keywords still worth targeting?How do I write SEO articles that help my business?Is SEO suitable for my industry?How do I write titles customers want to click?How can I tell whether an SEO tactic breaks spam rules?Why do I have keyword rankings but no customers?Where should I start if I want to do SEO myself?How do I choose SEO keywords that can bring customers?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR