CMS SEO Challenges: How Flexible Should Page Settings, Templates, and URL Design Be?

ProcrustesPR

The SEO challenges of a CMS go beyond how easily content can be updated. They also include whether individual pages can have their own settings, whether templates can be modified, and whether URLs and navigation are easy to plan. In a 2004 Search Engine Journal article, Jim Hedger recommends involving SEO consultants early in development to avoid discovering system limitations after launch. The following summarizes the issues and design recommendations in that historical article, not the capabilities of all current CMS platforms or today’s search engine ranking rules.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRShould You Use a Website Platform? Decide Based on Maintenance, Expansion, and Migration Needs

Individual pages need their own settings, not one shared configuration for the entire site

The author notes that when different pages target different sets of keywords, using the same title and metadata across the site limits the scope for adjustment. He places particular importance on meta description tags that reflect the page’s topic, but this was his assessment at the time, not a definitive statement about current ranking factors.

  • Allow each page to have its own title and metadata rather than requiring it to use sitewide settings.
  • Allow individual page footers to be modified, so users do not discover this limitation only when they need to make a change.

The original article describes a situation in which an SEO professional is hired to work on multiple sets of keywords but can use only one generic title for the entire website. The system should therefore offer enough flexibility in its settings to meet different pages’ needs.

Templates should be adjustable and support clear navigation

Based on the author’s experience at the time, many CMS templates were too rigid to accommodate necessary changes. He recommends consulting SEO professionals when creating templates to determine which elements need to be adjustable and which can remain fixed. He also suggests providing a separate homepage template with key areas that can be modified.

Template limitations can also affect navigation. The author’s approach was to place a text-based navigation map at the bottom of each page, giving search engine crawlers clear paths to follow. However, he had encountered systems in which even adding a footer was difficult. This is a specific approach proposed in the original article, not a requirement for every modern website to adopt the same footer layout.

Discuss changes to database-generated URLs early

For CMS platforms with database-generated URLs, the author’s concern was that question marks, parameter symbols, and numeric codes made it difficult to include keywords in internal page URLs. He also acknowledges that search engines at the time could already follow most URLs to crawl pages, so his argument should not be reduced to the claim that URLs with parameters cannot be crawled.

He recommends planning a clearer URL structure during development. URL changes become harder to manage once a website is in use, has acquired external links, and has staff continually adding content. This recommendation does not guarantee that clearer URLs will improve rankings.

Updates by multiple contributors also require advance communication

The original article also notes that a CMS makes it easier for multiple departments to update content, which can lead to frequent changes in product and sales information. The author recommends that companies tell their SEO teams what content will change and when, and establish standards for updating and adding product information. The emphasis is on coordinating changes, not claiming that frequent updates necessarily harm rankings.

At Procrustes, for example, our services cover page planning, design, and feature development for partner websites, as well as content topic planning, writing, and updates.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow Do B2B Companies Use Blogs and Content Management Systems?

CMS and SEO: Further Questions

What other work-related challenges might SEO professionals encounter when using different CMS platforms?

Another challenge is the time needed to learn an unfamiliar system. The original 2004 article notes that CMS platforms differ in design, so SEO professionals need time to learn how to use them. In the author's experience at the time, this took up working hours, but SEO professionals were generally reluctant to pass their own learning costs on to clients. The time needed to become familiar with a system can therefore be discussed during project planning. This reflects professional experience at the time, not a claim that all CMS platforms today lack standardization.

ProcrustesPRHow Should a CMS Handle Images? From Upload Optimization to Descriptions and URL Management

References

  1. Search Engine Optimization and Dynamic Technologieswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2004-05-07T12:12:23+00:00 — Discusses: What other work-related challenges might SEO professionals encounter when using different CMS platforms?

Related articles

Should You Use a Website Platform? Decide Based on Maintenance, Expansion, and Migration NeedsHow Do B2B Companies Use Blogs and Content Management Systems?How Should a CMS Handle Images? From Upload Optimization to Descriptions and URL ManagementWhat are the features, benefits, and limitations of a CMS?How does a headless CMS work, and what are its benefits and trade-offs?How to Choose Between Wix, WordPress.com, and WordPress.orgWhat types of WordPress are available, and what advantages does each offer for building a website?How can you build a responsive website without coding or Photoshop skills?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR