SEO is worth investing in for most businesses, especially when potential customers use search to find products or services. But needing SEO does not necessarily mean outsourcing it. Businesses using SEO services primarily aim to attract their target audience, reach new customers, and build brand awareness and trust. These are service goals, not guaranteed results. SEO is a long-term investment, and survey findings about other businesses do not mean your own investment will pay off.
Start by asking whether customers search for your products
Semrush argues that most businesses need SEO because many people use search during the buying process. If a business does not address those search needs, competitors may rank higher for relevant keywords, potentially costing it visibility and traffic. That makes the need for SEO worth assessing, but it does not mean every company should commit the same budget.
SEO also involves more than adding keywords to web pages. The work includes:
- Understanding what users search for and identifying needs relevant to the business.
- Creating content that meets searchers’ needs.
- Making technical improvements to the website so search engine crawlers can access its content.
- Earning links from relevant, high-quality websites.
Outsourcing usually helps fill gaps in in-house expertise or resources
Backlinko lists several reasons for using SEO services: a lack of expertise, insufficient resources, a belief that outsourcing is more cost-effective, poor results from in-house efforts, and a lack of time. Whether a business needs SEO and whether it should hire a provider are separate questions. First, assess whether the business needs to reach potential customers through search; then decide who should do the work.
For example, a business with content staff but no technical SEO expertise could prioritize discussing how a provider would fill that gap. If the in-house team lacks time to do the work, it should first clarify which tasks the provider will actually handle. These are ways to assess providers based on the reasons above, not evidence that outsourcing is necessarily cheaper or more effective than doing the work in-house.
At Procrustes, for example, our services cover page planning, design, and functionality for partner websites, as well as content topic planning, writing, updates, and ongoing work to build visibility.
Seek traffic and new customers, but recognize that returns take time
In the customer survey cited by Backlinko, key expectations included acquiring new customers, increasing traffic, raising brand awareness, and building trust. Social media followers, newsletter subscribers, and recruitment were relatively less important. When discussing SEO, rather than focusing only on social media likes, first establish which searchers you want to attract, how the services will help meet your goals, and how reports will show the relevant results.
Backlinko’s article also cites a 2025 survey in which 91% of respondents using SEO services reported a positive impact on website performance and progress toward marketing goals. These are respondents’ reported results, not a success rate for all businesses or a measure of revenue growth.
The same source states that many SEO campaigns take 6–12 months to recoup their costs, but this is not a fixed timeline. Slow returns, unclear reporting, or mismatched expectations can all cause frustration. Providers should therefore explain their approach and ensure that their work and reporting match the outcomes they promise, rather than showcase impressive-looking numbers while overlooking the goals that truly matter to the business.
SEO for businesses: perspectives from across the web
Can paid search advertising replace SEO?
Overall comparisons of click-through rates or cost-effectiveness alone cannot determine whether paid search can replace SEO. Paid search advertising also provides visibility in search results, but requires paying for clicks. Semrush argues that PPC (pay-per-click advertising) is generally less cost-effective than SEO and cites its 2023 search report, which found that paid results had a lower average click-through rate than organic results. This is an aggregate comparison from that report, not a reason for every business to abandon advertising or rely solely on SEO.
What factors can businesses consider when choosing an SEO provider?
Backlinko’s survey found that small business owners were more influenced by a provider’s reputation, fees, and its own Google rankings when choosing a provider; client case studies and social media presence had relatively less influence. These were factors respondents considered in their choices, not evidence that high rankings or a suitable price guarantee results.
References
- SEO FAQ: 25 Questions & Answers for Beginnerswww.semrush.com · 2020-10-22T13:20:00Z — Discusses: Can paid search advertising replace SEO?
- The SEO Services Reportbacklinko.com · 2026-04-30T02:00:41-05:00 — Discusses: What factors can businesses consider when choosing an SEO provider?
