Broken links do more than lead people to error pages; they may also affect the search visibility of pages on a site. Their severity depends on where the links appear, how many there are, and what they are for. Broken internal links may affect search engine crawling and the flow of link equity between pages, while broken links to external sites primarily affect user experience and readers’ trust in the content. Finding broken links does not automatically mean rankings will drop, and there is insufficient evidence to use a fixed number to determine whether a site is seriously affected.
Broken internal and external links have different effects
A Semrush article marked as published in 2021 states that broken internal links make it harder for search engines to crawl a site and may interrupt the flow of link equity between pages, harming technical SEO and affecting search visibility. This does not mean that every broken link causes an observable drop in rankings.
The article takes a different view of broken links to external sites: they do not directly harm rankings, but they create a poor user experience and may reduce readers’ trust in the content. This is the explanation offered by that SEO article, not a penalty rule announced by a search platform.
Look beyond the error screen to the link’s purpose
When assessing the impact, start with what the link was meant to do:
- Direct readers to other pages on the same site: Readers cannot follow the intended path. Also check whether search engine crawling and links between pages are affected.
- Provide references on external sites: Readers cannot use the link to access the promised content. The main concerns are the reading experience and trust.
In a 1998 article, Jakob Nielsen noted that users become frustrated when they expect to reach a page but encounter a 404 or an unclear error message instead. This early article illustrates how broken links affect usability, but the survey figures it cites cannot be treated as current broken-link rates for websites.
Track the numbers, but there is no universal threshold for severity
“How many broken links are there?” and “What impact do they have?” are two different questions. The available material does not establish how many broken links, or what proportion, would harm rankings. We therefore cannot claim that a small number is necessarily harmless or that reaching a particular number will inevitably lead to a ranking penalty. When compiling a list, record not only the number but also whether the links lead to internal or external pages and what they are for. Do not draw conclusions from the total alone.
Check the site after launch and prioritize fixes by severity
Semrush’s 2023 post-launch checklist recommends auditing the site again to identify issues such as broken links that may have been missed during testing, then prioritizing fixes by severity. Common causes of broken links include deleting pages without updating links, changing URLs without proper redirects, and typos in URLs.
Identifying the cause helps determine whether to update a link, correct a URL, or check a redirect. A broken link alone is not enough to blame the site’s theme or speed.
Broken links: perspectives from across the web
Beyond affecting individual clicks, what other effects could widespread broken links have?
In 1998, Jakob Nielsen suggested that if broken links reduced the prevalence and usefulness of links between websites, the web could gradually become a collection of isolated islands of information. This was a warning about the web's overall interconnectedness, not proof that broken links on a particular site would cause that outcome. He also discussed other factors that could hinder free browsing, such as paid subscriptions.
What do past surveys tell us about how users felt about broken links?
In the 1997 GVU surveys, the proportion of respondents who identified broken links as a major problem with using the web rose from 50% in April to 60% in October. This shows that broken links were a concern for respondents at the time. However, the findings apply to a specific period and group of respondents; they cannot be used to infer how today's readers feel or treated as the current rate of broken links.
References
- Broken Links: Common Causes and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-06-07T21:58:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Fighting Linkrotwww.nngroup.com · 1998-06-14T05:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Beyond affecting individual clicks, what other effects could widespread broken links have?; What do past surveys tell us about how users felt about broken links?
- 2025 Website Launch Checklist (Pre-Launch and Post-Launch)www.semrush.com · 2023-09-13T14:54:00Z — Source used in the article above.

