A broken link fails to take visitors to its intended destination. Common causes include deleted pages, URL changes without proper redirects, mistyped URLs, and server problems. Broken links lead visitors to dead ends, and broken internal links may also hinder search engine crawling. However, not every broken link should be treated as a direct cause of declining rankings. Maintenance should start by distinguishing internal links from external links, then identifying why they fail and which problems you can address yourself. This article outlines assessment and maintenance principles; specific procedures for finding and fixing broken links are covered separately.
A Broken Link Does Not Mean the Content Is Permanently Gone
A 404 or another error message after clicking a link is a common sign of a broken link, but the underlying causes can differ. Welly’s 2025 article lists deleted pages, URL changes, and server problems. Semrush’s article also mentions misspelled URLs and missing or improperly configured redirects after pages move. Common situations include:
- A page has been deleted, but links to it in articles have not been updated.
- Content has moved to a new URL, but the old URL does not take visitors to the new location.
- A link contains an incorrect URL, or the destination website cannot respond properly because of server problems.
An error therefore does not necessarily mean the content is permanently gone. Different causes call for different responses.
Both Internal and External Links Need Maintenance, but What You Can Control Differs
Internal links point to pages on your own website, so you can change both the links and the destination URLs. External links point to other websites. You can change references on your own pages, but you cannot restore someone else’s content or manage their URLs.
For example, if an introductory page on your site still links to a product page that has moved, you can address that link problem yourself. If a report cited in an article disappears from an external website, you need to assess whether a reliable alternative source exists or remove the broken reference. Maintaining these links is different from finding broken links on other websites and recommending your own content to gain backlinks.
A Poorer User Experience Does Not Necessarily Mean Lower Rankings
Broken links interrupt navigation and may undermine readers’ trust in the content. Semrush notes that broken internal links make crawling more difficult and may interrupt the flow of link equity between pages. It considers broken external links a user experience problem rather than a direct cause of lower rankings.
Views on ranking effects differ. Welly suggests that large numbers of broken links and bounce rates may affect rankings. By contrast, Patrick Stox of Ahrefs argues in a 2022 article that the SEO benefits of fixing external links are difficult to substantiate and that this work is generally a lower maintenance priority. These views do not add up to a rule that “more broken links inevitably mean worse rankings.”
Define the Scope of Checks and Prioritize Maintenance
According to Semrush, a sitewide crawl audit can list broken internal and external links, the pages containing them, and HTTP status codes. A browser extension that checks individual pages is not a suitable substitute for a sitewide audit. Google Search Console also shows only errors Googlebot has encountered, so it should not be treated as a complete list of errors.
A 2025 article on Neil Patel’s website recommends monthly checks and prioritizing broken internal links. This is maintenance advice, not an official requirement. External links can be prioritized according to user needs. For example, Ahrefs recommends addressing frequently clicked links first, rather than assuming every repair will improve rankings.
Broken links: perspectives from across the web
Can a custom 404 page replace fixing broken links?
Not entirely. A custom 404 page can offer related topics, products, or categories when visitors reach a page that does not exist, helping them continue browsing. However, it does not automatically restore the intended content. If a correct URL or a new location for the content is available, the original link should still be addressed so that subsequent visitors do not repeatedly encounter the error.
How should old URLs be handled when content moves or becomes outdated?
When a page moves, its old URL can be retained and redirected to the new location so visitors following old links can still find the content. If the content is genuinely outdated, such as a registration page for an event that has ended, Nielsen recommends removing the original page while still directing its old URL to follow-up information or the closest relevant current page. This is maintenance advice, not a requirement to preserve every old page unchanged.
Does finding an archived copy of a page resolve a broken link?
Not necessarily. An archived copy lets people consult a page's past content and can be a useful reference when the original page is no longer accessible. However, Ahrefs' 2022 article notes that relying on archives does not truly resolve broken links or changes to web content. Archived content should also be understood in the context of when it was saved, rather than automatically treated as current information.
References
- Broken Links: Common Causes and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-06-07T21:58:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- 失效連結(Broken Links)怎麼處理?這 2 工具幫你檢查、修復welly.tw · 2025-01-23T09:32:05.799Z — Source used in the article above.
- internal Link Broken?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can a custom 404 page replace fixing broken links?
- Fighting Linkrotwww.nngroup.com · 1998-06-14T05:00:00+0000 — Discusses: How should old URLs be handled when content moves or becomes outdated?
- The Ultimate Monthly Website Maintenance Checklistneilpatel.com · 2025-07-16T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- At Least 66.5% of Links to Sites in the Last 9 Years Are Dead (Ahrefs Study on Link Rot)ahrefs.com · 2022-04-29T06:40:30+00:00 — Discusses: Does finding an archived copy of a page resolve a broken link?
- internal Link Broken?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can a custom 404 page replace fixing broken links?

