Choose a breadcrumb type based on navigation needs: prioritize hierarchy-based breadcrumbs when readers need to know which category a page belongs to; use attribute-based breadcrumbs to show applied product filters such as color and size; and consider path-based breadcrumbs when you need to show the pages a user has actually visited. These answer “Where am I?”, “What have I selected?”, and “How did I get here?”, respectively. They are not interchangeable simply because they look similar.
These navigation questions are also part of website planning. At Procrustes, our services include page planning, design, and functionality development for the websites we work on with clients.
Hierarchy-based breadcrumbs: for stable categories and access to parent pages
Corporate websites, blogs, media sites, and general e-commerce sites can prioritize hierarchy-based breadcrumbs if they already have clearly defined categories. For example, “Home > Blog > SEO > Breadcrumbs” shows a page’s position within the site structure, not the reader’s click history. Even readers arriving directly from search results can see which topic the article belongs to.
A 2021 Semrush article notes that this format helps users arriving through organic search discover other relevant content. It provides access to parent categories without requiring readers to have navigated from the homepage first. A page’s category path is generally fixed, which also makes it easier to maintain a consistent hierarchy.
Attribute-based breadcrumbs: for e-commerce sites with multiple filters
When shoppers need to check which filters they have selected, attribute-based breadcrumbs are more useful than a simple category list. For example, in “Home > Women’s Shoes > Sneakers > White > 24 cm,” “White” and “24 cm” are filter values, not necessarily levels in the site hierarchy.
- Hierarchy-based breadcrumbs indicate which category a product belongs to.
- Attribute-based breadcrumbs show what the displayed products have in common or which filters the user has selected.
- The two can be used together; there is no need to choose just one.
If different filter combinations generate separate URLs that search engines can crawl, you also need to plan how to handle filtered pages, canonical tags, and indexing controls. This helps prevent large numbers of pages with similar content or limited search value from being indexed. The risk arises under particular URL structures; it does not mean that all attribute-based breadcrumbs create duplicate-content problems.
Path-based breadcrumbs: for retracing browsing history, not showing a fixed structure
Path-based breadcrumbs list pages in the order a user actually visited them, such as “Search Page > Category Page > Product Page.” If the goal is to return to recently viewed pages, they can show that journey. However, different people may reach the same product page by different routes, so the trail should not be treated as a fixed category hierarchy.
Da Vinci’s 2026 overview notes that this functionality resembles the browser’s back button and is less commonly used as the main breadcrumb format. It recommends prioritizing hierarchy-based breadcrumbs for most websites. This is design advice, not a rule prohibiting path-based breadcrumbs.
Deeply nested pages: check whether users also need navigation between pages at the same level
In its 2021 discussion of horizontal local navigation, NN/g notes that this form of navigation can accommodate roughly two to three levels in practice; more deeply nested pages may benefit from more compact breadcrumbs instead. However, breadcrumbs do not show pages at the same level. If users frequently switch between those pages, saving space cannot be the only consideration.
Whether to replace local navigation with breadcrumbs still depends on the site’s overall depth and the pages users need to move between during a single browsing session. A site having more than three levels does not automatically mean its local navigation should be replaced.
When to use each type of breadcrumb: perspectives from across the web
When a page belongs to multiple categories, will its breadcrumbs always show the same path as its local navigation?
Not necessarily. In one example discussed by NN/g in 2021, a page belonged to multiple hierarchies, and the path shown in its local navigation differed from the visible breadcrumb trail. When designing this kind of site, pay attention to the category relationships presented by both forms of navigation. However, a single example does not mean that these paths will necessarily differ on every site with multiple hierarchies.
References
- 麵包屑(Breadcrumb)是什麼?功能、類型、SEO重要性與WordPress設定教學www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2026-07-23T08:38:38+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Local Navigation Is a Valuable Orientation and Wayfinding Aidwww.nngroup.com · 2021-07-04T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: When a page belongs to multiple categories, will its breadcrumbs always show the same path as its local navigation?
- What Are Breadcrumbs? SEO Implications & Best Practiceswww.semrush.com · 2021-09-14T14:57:00Z — Source used in the article above.

