How Does Breadcrumb Markup Differ? Comparing HTML, Microdata, and JSON-LD Implementations

ProcrustesPR

The main differences in breadcrumb markup concern how navigation is presented and where structured data is placed: HTML creates the path readers can see; Microdata adds structured information to existing HTML tags; JSON-LD describes the path through data that is not directly displayed on the page. Your choice should take layout and maintenance into account, rather than treating any syntax as a guarantee that breadcrumbs will appear in search results.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWill structured data improve rankings or AI citations?

First, distinguish visible navigation from structured data

For a path such as “Books › Science Fiction › Award Winners,” the page needs to make the order and hierarchy clear to readers. Welly’s 2021 tutorial uses HTML ol and li elements to build a list, then adds names and links for each level. Structured data describes the items and positions along that path so search engines can understand it.

HTML and JSON-LD should therefore not be treated as mutually exclusive alternatives. The former handles visible content, while the latter can separately describe the same path. Semrush also notes that Google can use breadcrumb markup to build navigation paths in search results, but their display is not guaranteed.

Microdata and JSON-LD differ in how data is incorporated into the page

  • Microdata: Appears alongside HTML tags, adding structured information to the page’s existing content. When comparing implementations, consider it together with the underlying HTML.
  • JSON-LD: The data itself is not directly displayed on the page. Welly’s tutorial notes that its placement is more flexible, making it suitable for pages with specific visual layout requirements. However, this does not mean it automatically creates visible navigation.

In a 2019 article, awoo argued that neither format is inherently superior. Welly’s team recommended JSON-LD in 2021 because its syntax is intuitive and generators are available. These are implementation judgments made by different teams, not official requirements, and they do not imply that JSON-LD necessarily leads to better rankings.

The visible page structure still needs attention—not just the data format

An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange recommends presenting breadcrumbs as an ordered or unordered list, optionally wrapped in a nav element. It also advises against putting the entire path into a heading. This is community advice on semantic structure and should not be reframed as a mandatory search engine rule.

Using book categories as an example, the list presents the sequence “Books, Science Fiction, Award Winners.” When using JSON-LD, you still need to handle the names and links readers see separately.

When plugins and tags coexist, first identify the data sources

In a Warrior Forum case, a poster was using Yoast, a GTM breadcrumb tag, and an additional plugin at the same time, but could not determine which was generating anomalous data. After they disabled the additional plugin and paused the GTM tag, the identifier values returned to normal in testing.

This case did not establish which setting caused the problem, nor did it confirm that search results had been corrected as well. The takeaway is that, beyond comparing syntax, you should identify what is actually generating the output. The mere presence of a plugin does not establish that it is responsible for the problem.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow to choose a CMS for SEO: start with control over features and your team’s needs

Breadcrumb markup: perspectives from across the web

If a product page already has product structured data, do breadcrumbs need to go in the same code block?

Not necessarily. Semrush’s product page tutorial states that breadcrumbs can use a separate code snippet and do not need to be included in the product object. The product object can describe product attributes such as price, availability, and aggregate ratings, while breadcrumbs describe the page’s position in the site hierarchy. If a product page needs to include both types of information, it can use a separate code snippet for each.

After adding structured data, do you still need to consider accessible navigation?

Yes. Even after adding structured data, you still need to consider whether the navigation itself is accessible. Structured data describes breadcrumb information and should not replace accessible navigation design. An iThome implementation article recommends following HTML5, WAI, and structured data practices, using appropriate navigation markup and accessibility attributes for breadcrumbs. These are implementation recommendations, however, and the available excerpts do not provide enough information to list all required attributes.

ProcrustesPRHow do you choose and use WordPress SEO plugins?

References

  1. "Null" instead of website folder directory - Breadcrumb issue in the SERP?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. 麵包屑(Breadcrumb)是什麼?優化 SEO 排名的導覽路徑!welly.tw · 2021-12-20T05:05:37.875Z — Source used in the article above.
  3. How to Use Rich Results for Ecommerce to Improve SERP Visibilitywww.semrush.com · 2019-01-02T08:00:00Z — Discusses: If a product page already has product structured data, do breadcrumbs need to go in the same code block?
  4. Breadcrumb, 決定 SEO 的 25 項標準與通訊協定系列 XIVithelp.ithome.com.tw — Discusses: After adding structured data, do you still need to consider accessible navigation?
  5. SEO基本功!麵包屑(Breadcrumbs)讓搜尋引擎愛上你www.awoo.ai · 2019-10-03T04:00:33+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  6. What is schema markup? And how to add it to your sitewww.semrush.com · 2023-12-19T09:04:00Z — Discusses: If a product page already has product structured data, do breadcrumbs need to go in the same code block?
  7. h1 including breadcrumb linkswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

Will structured data improve rankings or AI citations?How to choose a CMS for SEO: start with control over features and your team’s needsHow do you choose and use WordPress SEO plugins?How can content, links, and structured data help build website credibility?What elements appear on Google search results pages, and why does their appearance vary?How Can Websites Improve E-E-A-T or E-A-T? Start with Content, Authors, and Trust InformationHow Can Understanding Google Search Result Elements Help SEO?How do you plan keywords and create and optimize content for voice search?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR