Including a blog link may affect how persuasive readers find an article, but a link alone does not tell us whether the article is credible. One commenter felt an article would be more convincing without its link. That is one reader’s view of a particular article, not evidence that links detract from every article. Someone posting a link may simply want to provide more complete content. These views reflect different considerations; neither establishes that a link itself makes an article untrustworthy.
One commenter says “more convincing without the link,” but does not explain why
A PTT comment reads: “Wouldn’t this article be more convincing if it had no blog links at all?” For this commenter, the presence of a blog link did affect how persuasive the article seemed.
However, the comment does not explain why. Was the concern about driving traffic to a blog, having to navigate elsewhere while reading, or some other dissatisfaction with the article? We cannot answer for the commenter. Thinking an article would be better without a link is not the same as identifying an error in its arguments, nor does it establish that most readers share that view.
The poster’s explanation: conclusions on the forum, a link to the full text
Separately, a Mobile01 poster said the original article was lengthy, so they put the conclusions on the forum and linked to the original for anyone who wanted to read it in full. According to the poster, the link offered access to the full text rather than entirely replacing the explanation on the forum.
Beyond whether a link affects persuasiveness, this raises another question: if the forum post contains only the conclusions, where can readers find the full argument? Still, this is the poster’s explanation of their own approach. It does not establish the article’s quality or prove that readers accept the arrangement. It is unclear whether this post and the PTT comment came from the same discussion, so they cannot be treated as a direct exchange.
Content and compliance with forum rules are separate questions
The Mobile01 poster also said they had contacted the site administrators to check whether the post violated the forum rules. If it did, or if most forum users considered the link inappropriate, they were willing to remove it and continue the discussion using text only. This states what the poster was willing to do; it does not mean the administrators had issued a ruling. When reading disputes like this, keep at least three things distinct:
- Reader assessment: A commenter did say the article would be more convincing without a link, but gave no specific reason.
- The poster’s rationale: The poster said the link gave readers access to the full content, but that does not mean others accepted the approach.
- Platform rules: Asking for clarification does not mean permission has been granted, nor does it mean a violation has been found.
A link may therefore affect how readers assess an article, but its presence or absence alone is not enough to judge the article’s content or the poster’s motives.
Blog links and article persuasiveness: perspectives from across the web
Does removing a blog link necessarily make an article more persuasive?
Not necessarily. One PTT comment suggested that the article in question would be more convincing without its blog link, but it neither explained why nor compared readers’ actual reactions. This is only one reader’s assessment of a particular article; it does not establish that removing links improves every article’s persuasiveness.
Does including a blog link mean an article is less credible?
A link alone is not enough to make that judgment. A Mobile01 poster said that because the original article was too long, they kept the conclusions on the forum and provided a link for anyone who wanted to read the full content. This is their own account of the link’s purpose, not sufficient evidence that the article is credible or that readers will accept it. A separate PTT commenter, meanwhile, felt an article would be more convincing without a link.
References
- 怎麼做SEO優化?www.mobile01.com — Discusses: Does including a blog link mean an article is less credible?
- [心得] 部落格的流量迷思www.ptt.cc — Discusses: Does removing a blog link necessarily make an article more persuasive?; Does including a blog link mean an article is less credible?


