Should you submit a blog comment feed to Google as a sitemap?

ProcrustesPR

Based on these public discussions, if you have already submitted a feed linking to your article pages, and the comment feed merely points to comment locations within those same articles, there is generally no need to submit it separately as a sitemap. The main reasons are that the comment feed may not provide URLs for different pages, and the comments may not deserve more emphasis than the main content. If reviews themselves make up the page’s main content, you can reassess. These are contributors’ views, however, not official Google rules, and they do not establish that submitting the feed will improve indexing or rankings.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?

First, distinguish between article pages and comment locations within a page

One answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange notes that even if RSS can serve as an alternative to an XML sitemap, not every type of RSS feed is worth submitting separately. The answer objects to submitting the comment feed it describes because its URLs use fragments—the parts after “#”—to point to locations within the same page, rather than to different pages.

For example, if two comments point to “#comment-1” and “#comment-2” within the same article, only their locations within the page differ. According to this answer, that is not the same as providing URLs for two different pages. Check the URLs actually listed in the feed rather than assuming it is worth submitting as another sitemap simply because it is continually updated.

The case for a separate submission is weaker when an article feed has already been submitted

Another answer sees no need to submit a comment feed if a feed linking to article pages has already been submitted. The contributor believes Google places more importance on articles than on comments, but provides no official basis for that view. It therefore cannot be treated as Google’s fixed assessment of all comments.

  • When submission might be worth considering: If comments or reviews are the page’s main content, you can reassess whether to submit a comment feed.
  • Main limitation: If it still points only to different fragments within existing articles, submitting it separately does not provide URLs for different pages.
  • Unverified effects: These discussions provide no results for indexing, rankings, or traffic, so they do not establish that submitting a comment feed is an effective optimization method.

Reviews taking up more space than the main text are a reason to reassess, not a submission threshold

One answer uses Zappos as an example, suggesting that a comment feed may be worth submitting when comments and reviews take up more space than the product copy. Another argues that comments are usually not the most valuable part of a page and therefore do not warrant special emphasis for search engines. The contributors differ in how they judge the value of comments, but neither sets a numerical threshold.

The discussions also include broader advice to keep adding content, comments, and articles, and to create and submit an RSS feed. That advice does not directly answer whether a comment feed should also be submitted when an article feed already exists. The more cautious approach is to check the URL structure and whether comments make up the page’s main content, then decide whether there is a reason for a separate submission, rather than submitting every feed indiscriminately.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhere should I start if I want to do SEO myself?

Comment feeds as sitemaps: perspectives from across the web

If every comment in a comment feed has a different URL, does that make the feed worth submitting?

Not necessarily. If the URLs simply append different “#” fragments to the same article page, one contributor considers them locations within a page rather than separate pages, making the case for an additional submission weaker. This judgment applies to the URL structure described in that answer; it cannot be applied directly if the feed actually lists URLs in other forms.

When might submitting a comment feed be worth considering?

If comments and reviews take up more space than the page’s main text, it may be worth reconsidering whether to submit the feed. One contributor suggests that submission might be worthwhile when product reviews take up more space than the product copy; another argues that comments are usually not the most valuable part of a page. Having more review content than product copy is only a possible exception worth considering, not a submission threshold or a guarantee that submission will be effective.

What benefits or drawbacks could submitting a comment feed bring?

These discussions do not establish specific benefits or drawbacks of submitting a comment feed: they provide too little information about how indexing, rankings, or traffic changed after submission. Contributors mainly question whether submission is necessary. If a feed already links to article pages and the comment feed only points to locations within those same pages, a separate submission may be unnecessary. That does not mean submitting it will result in a penalty.

ProcrustesPRShould I rewrite or update an old article that does not rank?

References

  1. What are the best ways to improve a site's position in Google?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. Do or don't submit the comment-feed of your blog?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: When might submitting a comment feed be worth considering?; What benefits or drawbacks could submitting a comment feed bring?
  3. Do or don't submit the comment-feed of your blog?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: If every comment in a comment feed has a different URL, does that make the feed worth submitting?; When might submitting a comment feed be worth considering?

Related articles

How Long Does It Take to Evaluate SEO Results?Where should I start if I want to do SEO myself?Should I rewrite or update an old article that does not rank?What should I check when organic traffic suddenly drops?Why can I not find my published article on Google?Will Reposting Social Content on My Website Cause a Duplicate-Content Penalty?Eight SEO essentials for beginners: Getting your pages indexedWhat Is SEO? Understanding Optimization Priorities Through How Search Engines Work
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR