Is It Necessary to Block All Third-Party Bots?

ProcrustesPR

There is usually no need to block every bot simply because it comes from a third party. More useful questions are what it does, which content it accesses, how much it costs you, and whether you need the visibility it provides. If the goal is to restrict model training or competitors’ data scraping, a blanket block may also prevent search and retrieval access. If content licensing is a primary concern for your site, however, a stricter policy may be reasonable. This is not a binary choice between allowing everything and blocking everything; it is about deciding the scope of access based on purpose.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRDo we still need SEO now that AI answers questions?

First, clarify what you want to protect

A July 2026 Search Engine Journal article recommends treating each AI crawler as a separate business decision, weighing costs, visibility, and risks rather than allowing or rejecting them all. An interviewee in another report that September noted that publishers who want crawlers to pay for content have different needs from small businesses that want customers to find them. This is a business trade-off, not a rule every website must follow.

  • If resource consumption is your concern: assess the cost of visits from each bot rather than assuming that third-party status automatically makes it a burden.
  • If content use is your concern: distinguish between model training, search and retrieval, and user-initiated access.
  • If business data is your concern: consider public descriptions separately from pricing, inventory, and account data.

Bots from the same provider do not necessarily need the same permissions

A June 2026 Seer Interactive article notes that a single provider may use different bots for different tasks and recommends setting policies according to both purpose and content type. Its suggested starting point is to let identified, legitimate search and retrieval crawlers access public marketing content, product descriptions, and reviews; set separate access requirements for pricing and inventory; and reserve transactions for authorized agents.

For example, a store that wants its product descriptions to be discoverable but does not want unrestricted access to its pricing and inventory need not treat the entire site as a single category of data. This approach is only the author’s suggested starting point. It still needs to be adjusted to the website’s goals, platform, and risk tolerance; it is not an official, universal policy.

Blanket blocking can also affect human visitors

In an anecdotal reply on Warrior Forum, a contributor said that while checking a website, they found that its robots.txt blocked all search engine bots and that their own IP address was blocked after browsing just a few pages. This does not prove that all protective measures misclassify visitors, but it reminds site owners that crawler rules and visitor blocking need to be checked separately. If protection also blocks normal browsing, broader blocking does not necessarily mean a more appropriate policy.

Writing blocking rules does not confirm that they work

Another forum contributor cautioned that some bots ignore robots.txt. Seer Interactive also notes that a User-Agent name is merely a self-declared identity and cannot, on its own, verify who is accessing the site. A rules file therefore cannot be treated as a guarantee of comprehensive blocking. A November 2026 Search Engine Journal article recommends first checking how existing bot-protection software handles AI agents, then explicitly documenting which uses to allow, restrict, or block, rather than letting software settings make the decision for the website.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRWhat is AI visibility?

Blocking third-party bots: perspectives from across the web

Does restricting AI training mean sacrificing visibility in AI search?

Not necessarily. The iThome article recommends treating crawling for training separately from search indexing. If a provider offers separate controls for these purposes, consider restricting only training while preserving opportunities to appear in search results. However, services may use different bots and controls, so each service needs to be checked individually. A blanket block on AI crawlers may affect search indexing and visibility as well.

Can blocking AI crawlers solve problems associated with visitors referred by AI services?

Not directly. The iThome article notes that human visitors who follow links from AI services to a website are not crawlers, so crawler blocking does not directly address those visits. If your concern is the actual value of referral traffic, visitor behavior should be evaluated separately. The article also cautions that referral measurement has blind spots; you cannot assume every source can be clearly identified.

How can you decide whether a particular AI crawler is worth allowing?

Treat it as an individual decision, weighing the cost of its visits, potential visibility, associated risks, and future value. The Search Engine Journal article also suggests assessing whether its activity generates citations, referral traffic, or conversions, though these benefits may not all be easy to measure. Whether to allow access still depends on the website’s goals; the bot’s name alone is not enough to decide.

Does blocking training bots now mean older content will no longer be used?

You cannot draw that conclusion. The publisher dispute reported by Search Engine Journal highlights existing archived data as a separate issue from future crawling: content collected in the past may still be available for training. The effect of new blocking rules and the handling of existing data therefore need to be checked separately. Blocking should not be equated with deleting previously collected data.

ProcrustesPRHow does data quality affect a website’s readiness for the agentic web?

References

  1. Why is my website not cached on Google, but its pages are indexed?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. Here’s Why You Should (Still) Allow GPTBot to Crawl Your Sitewww.seerinteractive.com · 2026-06-15T00:00:00-05:00 — Source used in the article above.
  3. Should I Block AI Crawlers Or Measure Their Value First? – Ask An SEOwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-07-02T09:30:54+00:00 — Discusses: How can you decide whether a particular AI crawler is worth allowing?
  4. How To Build Local Pages AI Systems Can Find And Trustwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-09-21T12:00:25+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  5. 三種 AI 流量:訓練爬取、即時檢索、AI 導流,他們的行為完全不同ithelp.ithome.com.tw — Discusses: Does restricting AI training mean sacrificing visibility in AI search?; Can blocking AI crawlers solve problems associated with visitors referred by AI services?
  6. US Publishers Demand Common Crawl Stop Scraping Their Contentwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-10T00:45:20+00:00 — Discusses: Does blocking training bots now mean older content will no longer be used?
  7. Businesses Treat Your AI Agent 3 Different Wayswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-11-04T20:00:33+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  8. If I want to block third party bots to crawl my website, what I have to do?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.

Related articles

Do we still need SEO now that AI answers questions?What is AI visibility?How does data quality affect a website’s readiness for the agentic web?How will AI change SEO work and search traffic?What Is Search Everywhere Optimization, and Why Do You Need It?Why do publishers need SEO, and what challenges does AI bring?Which SEO Best Practices Matter Most? Applying Them to AI Search and E-commerceWhat Role Does Organic Search Play in B2B and AI Search?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR