If a URL still does not appear in Bing search results about 30 hours after submission, that alone does not mean the submission failed. The public discussions cited here offer no guaranteed indexing timeframe and do not establish that manual submission is necessarily faster than normal crawling. The key is to distinguish between URL discovery, page crawling, and content indexing. The claim of “almost immediate indexing” comes from an account of a 2011 interview and should not be treated as a current commitment. Nor does finding a few pages in search results after submission mean that submission caused them to be indexed.
Submitting a URL does not mean it has been indexed
Participants point out that crawling and indexing are separate processes. Submission is intended to prompt a search engine to crawl a URL, but whether the content enters the index may still depend on factors such as content uniqueness and links. This is an explanation offered in the discussion, not a current Bing service guarantee.
- Discovery: The search engine learns that a URL exists, possibly through submission or through links on websites.
- Crawling: The crawler actually reads the page; knowing that a URL exists does not mean it has been read.
- Indexing: Submission alone cannot confirm whether a page has been indexed.
Having a Sitemap and some content already indexed is therefore not enough to conclude that newly submitted pages will necessarily be indexed faster. The discussions cited here provide no controlled comparison for this situation.
One day to over a month is an estimate, not a deadline
One participant estimated that the time could range from one day to over a month, mentioning external links, domain age, server configuration, and crawler processing time as possible factors. In his experience, new sites that started with a parked domain and basic content were usually discovered within three to four days. Another site, with a newly registered domain, little link-building, and more niche content, took nearly a month.
These cases had different starting conditions. The time from going live to being “discovered” is not the same as the time from submission to indexing. These individual cases neither represent an average nor prove that any particular factor caused a delay. Another participant said that submitting through the form did not seem to speed things up; that, too, is only an individual observation.
Establish the starting point before judging whether submission is faster
About 30 hours after submitting the URLs, the original questioner found that a few pages appeared in search results. But those pages had already been live for a week and might have been indexed before submission. Without a record of their status beforehand, it is impossible to tell whether they were indexed before or after submission, much less what caused them to be indexed.
- Record when pages go live, when they are submitted, and whether they could be found in search before submission, so the starting points are clear.
- Following the discussion’s advice, check crawl statistics and error information in Webmaster Tools for obstacles to accessing or indexing the pages.
- When comparing normal crawling with manual submission, account for differences in publication timing, links, and content rather than comparing only the number of days spent waiting.
The account of the 2011 Duane Forrester interview claimed that URLs “go directly into the index and appear in results almost immediately.” However, the person relaying that statement explicitly said he did not know whether this happened in practice. That historical claim does not align with the reported waiting times. The discussions cited here cannot explain the difference or support a promise about indexing speed today.
Bing URL submission and indexing: perspectives from across the web
What should I do if most pages still cannot be found about 30 hours after submission?
First, check crawl statistics, indexing obstacles, and error information in Webmaster Tools, and address the issues it reports. The public discussions offer no guaranteed indexing timeframe. One participant estimated anything from one day to over a month, but that is not a standard waiting period after submission. Not appearing in results after 30 hours is not, on its own, proof that submission failed.
If I already have a Sitemap and some indexed pages, will manual submission be faster?
Not necessarily. The discussions cited here offer no controlled comparison for sites that already have a Sitemap and some indexed pages, so they cannot establish that manual submission is necessarily faster. One participant said that submitting through the form did not seem to speed things up. He also noted that only Bing knows how submitted URLs are prioritized, and that crawlers might discover the site through other routes first.
If a page can be found after submission, does that confirm submission caused it to be indexed?
No—not simply because it can be found after submission. Some pages mentioned in the public question had already been live for a week, and the questioner noted that they might have been indexed before submission. Without a record of their status beforehand, it is impossible to confirm whether indexing happened before or after submission. Even if that sequence is known, the pages may still have been discovered through other routes, so submission cannot automatically be credited with causing their indexing.
An interview said submitted URLs appear in results almost immediately. Is that reliable in practice?
That statement should not be treated as a current indexing commitment. An account of a 2011 interview claimed that URLs submitted through the tool would go directly into the index and appear in search results almost immediately. However, the person relaying the statement did not know whether it matched actual use. Another report described most pages still not appearing in results about 30 hours after submission. The material is insufficient to explain the difference.
References
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: If I already have a Sitemap and some indexed pages, will manual submission be faster?; If a page can be found after submission, does that confirm submission caused it to be indexed?
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: What should I do if most pages still cannot be found about 30 hours after submission?
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: An interview said submitted URLs appear in results almost immediately. Is that reliable in practice?
- How quickly does Bing index URLs submitted through Webmaster Tools?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: What should I do if most pages still cannot be found about 30 hours after submission?; If a page can be found after submission, does that confirm submission caused it to be indexed?
- Making search engine crawl my sitewebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: What should I do if most pages still cannot be found about 30 hours after submission?
