Author links appearing across many domains may result from articles republished through article directories, content syndication arranged through a PR agency, or large-scale content scraping. The domain count alone cannot establish which explanation applies, much less whether the links have value. What matters is which articles contain the links, whether they appear in author bios, and how the content reached other websites. The explanations below describe possible causes, not definitive conclusions about any particular website.
Article directories: author links may be retained when articles are republished
An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange explains that some article directories allow other websites to republish submitted content for free, provided they retain appropriate attribution, such as an author link in an “About the Author” section. As a result, when different websites use the same article, the author link may appear across multiple domains.
However, the chance to acquire many links does not mean those links are proven to help. The respondent said they had gained little benefit from these links and considered many of the republishing sites to be low-value automated blogs. They also mentioned hearing that others had benefited. These are personal experiences and secondhand reports shared in a discussion. They do not establish that all article directories produce the same results, nor are they official search engine rules.
Content syndication: check where content appears and whether it has canonical tags
Author links appearing across domains may also be the result of planned content syndication. In an article published by Ahrefs in September 2024, Mateusz Makosiewicz used NerdWallet as an example to explain that, if content is syndicated through a PR agency, you can check which websites published it and whether those pages have canonical tags.
- If you know there is a syndication arrangement, start by checking where the content actually appeared rather than looking only at the total number of links.
- The article recommends checking for canonical tags, but that does not mean every republished page has them.
- The article also does not establish that adding these tags guarantees rankings or link benefits. The recommendation is a check to perform, not a guarantee of results.
Large-scale scraping: the numbers are clues, not conclusions
The same Ahrefs article reported that more than 100 authors each had links to NerdWallet from at least 30 distinct domains, with the highest count reaching 303 domains for one author. The article’s author considered it very likely that this scale indicated someone was scraping the site’s content extensively.
Still, “very likely” does not mean certain. These figures reflect the article’s observations about NerdWallet at the time, not a universal threshold for identifying scraping. They do not justify declaring that any author’s links spanning more than 30 domains are problematic.
When reviewing these links, treat domain counts as a starting point for further investigation, then check the circumstances:
- If the links appear in author bios, check whether they were retained when the articles were republished.
- If you know there is a PR syndication arrangement, check where the content appeared and whether those pages have canonical tags.
- If the content has spread unusually widely, check whether scraping is involved.
Ultimately, you need to examine the actual pages rather than draw conclusions from domain counts alone.
Author links across many domains: perspectives from across the web
Some people say submitting articles widely can bring benefits. Can this be treated as a general rule?
No. In the discussion about article directories, the respondent personally considered these links to have little value. However, they also relayed accounts of people who bought and rewrote large quantities of articles, submitted them to hundreds of directories, and claimed that the accumulated links helped. Those accounts are secondhand: they neither establish effectiveness nor support the conclusion that submitting articles widely necessarily works. The differing experiences should be considered separately.
Can the domain counts in the case study be used directly to assess your own website?
They should not be applied directly. The NerdWallet case counted the distinct domains with links to the site for each author, not the combined number of domains across all authors. The article’s author considered this scale very likely to indicate extensive content scraping, but that was an interpretation of this particular case—not a threshold for determining whether other websites have been scraped.
References
- What role do article submission directories play in SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Some people say submitting articles widely can bring benefits. Can this be treated as a general rule?
- Unpacking NerdWallet’s SEO: 10 Things I Discoveredahrefs.com · 2024-09-27T10:40:52+00:00 — Discusses: Can the domain counts in the case study be used directly to assess your own website?



