The available information does not establish that making articles longer, adding a table of contents, or using exact-match keywords will improve search rankings. A 2024 analysis found some associations between article length, the presence of a table of contents, and rankings for large websites, but not the same patterns for small and medium-sized businesses. Keyword phrasing—whether the terms appeared together or separately—also showed no clear ranking pattern. These observations come from a specific sample and do not guarantee that changing any one of these elements will improve rankings.
Article length: average length is not a ranking threshold
Views differ on whether longer articles have a ranking advantage. Medon on Warrior Forum claimed that articles of 1,300 to 2,000 words were more likely to rank well than those of 500 words, but the cited comment did not describe any research methodology, so it cannot be treated as a general rule. By contrast, a 2023 overview by yesharris stated that word count itself is not a ranking factor and that there is no maximum or minimum word count requirement. This reflects the article’s account at the time; it should not be read as verification of current official guidance.
yesharris’s 2024 analysis made the following observations:
- Large websites: articles ranking in the top three averaged approximately 3,500 to 4,500 words, with higher rankings associated with higher average word counts.
- Small and medium-sized businesses: articles ranking in the top three averaged approximately 3,000 to 3,500 words, but there was no clear pattern between word count and ranking.
The analysis used each article’s ranking for the keyword that brought it the most organic traffic, not its rankings across all keywords. The author also cautioned that the averages had been rounded and that reaching a given length did not mean an article would achieve the corresponding ranking.
A 2020 article by awoo proposed a more practical criterion: whether an article is long enough to answer readers’ questions. Even if a competing article contains 4,000 words, a 500-word article does not necessarily need to be lengthened. Longer articles may address more needs, but excessive text can also obscure the original focus.
At Procrustes, our content services turn the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
Tables of contents: reading benefits are distinct from ranking associations
In the same 2024 analysis, higher-ranking articles on large websites were more likely to have a table of contents. Higher-ranking articles from small and medium-sized businesses, however, did not necessarily have one. This does not establish that adding a table of contents will improve rankings.
A clearer purpose of a table of contents is to give readers an overview before they read the article. The analysis also mentioned that table-of-contents headings might appear in search results and increase click-through rates, but this was only a potential benefit described at the time. These headings will not appear in search results for every article, and the possibility is not evidence of improved rankings.
Keyword phrasing: exact matches showed no consistent advantage
For the keyword “SEO tools,” for example, “Introducing 30 SEO tools” is an exact match, while “Introducing 30 tools essential for SEO optimization” separates the keyword’s terms. The 2024 analysis found no clear ranking pattern in the distribution of these two forms among articles ranking in the top 10 for either website category.
The sample also included articles that ranked on the first page without mentioning the keyword at all. The proportion was higher among small and medium-sized businesses than among large websites. This does not mean keywords can always be omitted. It only means that the available observations do not support the claim that exact-match phrasing is necessary to rank well. Nor do they guarantee that separating the terms will leave rankings unchanged for every query.
Article length, tables of contents, and keyword phrasing: perspectives from across the web
Should recipe articles be made longer to improve their rankings?
There is no need to make them longer simply to reach a word count. A 2018 SEO article recommended basing recipe length on the information readers need: some recipes require more explanation, while others do not. An interviewee in the article also said that the studies he had seen supporting better performance for longer articles did not cover recipes, DIY, or lifestyle content, so their findings should not be applied directly to those topics.
If a competitor's article is long, do you need to lengthen yours too?
Not necessarily. First, check whether the competitor answers reader questions that your article has missed, then add genuinely useful content. A 2020 article by awoo argued that longer articles may address more needs, but shorter articles may already satisfy search intent. Simply adding text may even obscure the original focus. A competitor's article being both longer and higher-ranking does not prove that word count is the reason.
What is a table of contents useful for?
A table of contents gives readers an overview of an article and helps them quickly understand its structure. A 2024 analysis also mentioned that table-of-contents headings might appear in search results and increase click-through rates, but this is only a possibility, not something that happens for every article. Decide whether to include one based on readers' needs, rather than treating it as a guarantee of better rankings.
Can you separate a keyword's terms if the exact phrase sounds unnatural?
You can consider separating the terms to make the text read more naturally, but there is no guarantee that doing so will have no effect on rankings for every query. In the 2024 analysis, neither exact-match nor separated keyword phrasing showed a clear ranking pattern among articles ranking in the top 10 for large websites or small and medium-sized businesses. This was an observation from that study's sample, not sufficient evidence to conclude that either approach is necessarily better.
References
- Article content strategy for rankingwww.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- 超完整懶人包:【Search Central Live Taipei 2023】 內容總整理www.yesharris.com · 2023-12-22T10:28:54+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 網站內容優化與文章字數有關嗎?來談內容行銷與SEO如何幫助網站排名www.awoo.ai · 2020-11-02T07:53:47+00:00 — Discusses: If a competitor's article is long, do you need to lengthen yours too?
- Advanced SEO for Food Bloggers: An Interview with Casey Markeewww.semrush.com · 2018-11-19T08:00:00Z — Discusses: Should recipe articles be made longer to improve their rankings?
- SEO第一頁分析報告:標題、關鍵字、文章字數會影響排名嗎?www.yesharris.com · 2024-11-20T14:10:52+08:00 — Discusses: What is a table of contents useful for?; Can you separate a keyword's terms if the exact phrase sounds unnatural?


