How should content teams respond to increasingly similar search results and AI content?

ProcrustesPR

When faced with increasingly similar search results and AI content, the priority is not to make articles longer or ban AI entirely, but to answer readers’ actual questions and provide information missing from existing search results. Use SEO tools to help understand audience needs rather than simply copying the outlines they provide. Understand your customers and what sets your products apart before deciding what to create. Draw on genuine experience, professional judgment, or original testing, and let AI help with the writing without skipping fact-checking. These are content strategy recommendations, not guarantees of rankings or citations by AI.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRCan AI-written articles work for SEO?

Similarity is not necessarily a problem; a lack of added value is the warning sign

In a 2019 Animalz article, Ryan Law noted that articles targeting the same keyword will inevitably cover some of the same information because they need to satisfy a shared search intent. Similar titles or basic concepts alone therefore do not make content valueless. Conversely, passing a plagiarism check does not establish originality.

His criticism concerns excessive reliance on existing search results: tools compile the common topics in ranking articles, and teams adopt them wholesale, even retaining subheadings and examples that do not fit their own needs. Combining several articles into one longer piece increases its length, but does not necessarily make it better at answering readers’ questions.

  • Keep the background information readers need to understand the issue; do not remove necessary content simply to be different.
  • Review each paragraph: beyond restating what others have said, does it offer new observations, evidence, or judgment?
  • Evaluate drafts for originality, clarity, and value to readers rather than merely chasing tool scores.

Find questions your brand can answer with content competitors cannot simply reuse

An October 2026 Search Engine Journal report quoted Bodnar as saying that marketers must first understand their customers, their product story, and what sets them apart from competitors, rather than expecting software to do that work. He proposed a test: if the same message still applies when you swap in any other company’s logo, it may simply be adding noise.

Use this test to ask specific questions when choosing topics: What situation is the reader in? Why is the product suitable or unsuitable? What information does the team have to support these judgments? For example, rather than writing another generic buying checklist, explain the trade-offs under different usage conditions—provided actual test data is available. Standing out is not just about having a distinctive tone; it requires content competitors cannot directly reuse.

At Procrustes, our content service turns the questions customers genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

Let AI help with writing, while people prepare the source material and check the facts

In a 2023 article, awoo author Chen Xitong advocated drawing on personal experience and expertise while remaining open to having AI do the writing. The article also warned that tools at the time could confidently produce incorrect information. With this approach, fluent prose should not be mistaken for verified facts.

In an October 2026 article, Marie Haynes recommended focusing on developing unique perspectives, gathering data, and conducting tests to keep a simple AI summary from fully replacing the content. In practice, prepare verifiable source material before asking AI to help organize it. When reviewing the draft, check each data source, the conditions under which each example applies, and whether the conclusions go beyond what the evidence supports. If no testing was conducted, do not present the content as a hands-on test; without firsthand experience, do not write as though you were personally involved.

ProcrustesPRProcrustesPRHow should you use AI for SEO keyword research?

Search result similarity and AI content: perspectives from across the web

Is E-E-A-T an algorithm or a set of principles for evaluating content?

The awoo article describes E-E-A-T as a set of principles for evaluating content, rather than a single algorithm. “Experience” was added in December 2022, emphasizing the value of firsthand experience. The article also argues that expertise helps produce in-depth insights that are difficult to imitate. This can guide content planning, but it does not mean that satisfying a checklist guarantees rankings.

Besides adding original information, how else can content be improved?

The awoo author recommends drawing on the “10x Content” approach introduced in 2015: beyond providing comprehensive, accurate answers, consider the reading experience across devices, whether the content is trustworthy and useful, and whether its presentation distinguishes it from similar work. This was the author’s content planning advice in 2023, not a current ranking rule, nor does it mean every article must have all of these characteristics.

What clues can existing page performance offer when choosing topics?

Marie Haynes recommends examining pages that receive more visibility in AI search features and comparing their click performance in conventional search to explore which content may help readers. She argues that firsthand experience, original images or research, and content that goes deeper than a summary are often what give a page additional value. However, an association between visibility and clicks cannot, on its own, establish that these characteristics caused the results; the report discussed in the article also did not provide click data at the time.

ProcrustesPRDo AI Text Watermarks Affect Search Rankings?

References

  1. Copycat Content: SEO Tools Got Us Here, Humans Will Get Us Outwww.animalz.co · 2019-10-28T00:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  2. HubSpot Lost 80% Of Its Traffic – CMO Kipp Bodnar Explains Why Revenue Kept Growingwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-29T12:00:46+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  3. 與 Google 演算法同行,讓你做好 SEO 沒煩惱!【2023/10 更新】www.awoo.ai · 2023-10-20T11:09:25+00:00 — Discusses: Is E-E-A-T an algorithm or a set of principles for evaluating content?; Besides adding original information, how else can content be improved?
  4. Google Changed Its Helpful Content Guidelines To Emphasize Good ‘Main Content’www.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-06T14:30:10+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  5. GSC’s New AI Overview Reporting: How Can We Use This Information?www.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-04T10:05:54+00:00 — Discusses: What clues can existing page performance offer when choosing topics?

Related articles

Can AI-written articles work for SEO?How should you use AI for SEO keyword research?Do AI Text Watermarks Affect Search Rankings?How can you improve AI-generated websites and their search performance?How Can Human-Led SEO Build a Long-Term Advantage?Which SEO practices or mistakes can affect rankings?What are the risks of AI-generated content, and how can it be improved?How Can AI Help Writers Overcome the Blank Page and Foster Creativity?
ProcrustesPR
ProcrustesPR