A 404 status means the page cannot be found, but does not explicitly say whether it is permanently gone. A 410 status means the resource is no longer available and is expected to remain that way permanently. The key considerations are whether the content is known to have been permanently removed and whether a suitable replacement page exists. Google’s documentation accepts either status for deleted pages with no similar replacement content. There is no need to switch all such pages to 410 to remove them from the index. The available information also does not establish that using 410 today will necessarily lead to faster removal.
404 does not mean a page will return; 410 more explicitly signals permanent removal
Both codes can be used for pages that no longer exist. The distinction is whether they explicitly signal that the page is permanently gone. An older HTTP specification quoted in a community discussion states that 410 applies when a resource is no longer available, has no forwarding address, and is expected to remain unavailable permanently. If it is unclear whether the removal is permanent, 404 should be used. This quotation helps explain the difference in meaning, but it should not be treated as a complete account of the current specification.
So 404 should not be read as “temporary failure,” nor is returning 404 for a permanently deleted page necessarily wrong. Google’s guidance explicitly allows deleted pages with no replacement content to return either 404 or 410.
Both can be used to remove pages from the index; the difference in speed is uncertain
Google’s documentation explains that both 404 and 410 tell search engines that a page does not exist and should not be indexed. For removing pages from the index, they serve the same purpose.
As for speed, a 2021 Semrush article claimed that 410 could get a page removed from the index faster, while another article said it “may speed up” removal. A community answer also stated that Google treated the two identically at the time. These sources differ in date and wording, so they do not justify promises about current removal timelines, much less claims that faster removal improves rankings.
Determine what has happened to the content before choosing a status code
- Deleted, with no similar replacement page: Google accepts either 404 or 410; when removal is known to be permanent, 410 conveys that more explicitly.
- Uncertain whether the content is permanently gone: 404 does not declare that the content is permanently unavailable.
- Moved, or has a clear replacement page: Use 301, as Google’s documentation advises. For example, when the same article moves to a new URL, direct visitors there rather than treating the content as gone.
- Operations are only temporarily suspended: Do not make the entire site return 404 or 410. Google’s guidance on pausing a website warns that this will remove its URLs from search results and suggests considering reduced site functionality instead.
Error-page text cannot replace the actual status code
A custom page that says “Content not found” does not mean the server has returned a 404. Google’s documentation requires a custom 404 page to return an actual 404 HTTP status code to prevent that page from being indexed.
For visitors, clearly explain that the page does not exist, maintain consistent navigation, and provide links to the homepage or popular articles, or a way to report broken links. An error page can offer helpful guidance while returning the correct status code. Making it useful does not require hiding the fact that the content no longer exists.
404 and 410: perspectives from across the web
Should a seasonal product that is temporarily out of stock return 404 or 410?
If the product is only seasonally out of stock and its page will remain available, the page should not return 404 or 410. Community advice is to keep the page, clearly state that the product is seasonal and currently out of stock, and optionally offer restock notifications. If both the product and its page are confirmed to be permanently removed, a separate assessment is needed.
Do deleted URLs still need to be crawlable by search engines?
If you want a crawler to learn from the HTTP response that a page has been removed, it must be able to crawl that URL. Google’s explanation, cited in the community discussion, states that if robots.txt blocks a URL, the crawler cannot see its 404 or 410 response. In other words, setting the correct status code and allowing crawling are two separate matters; this does not mean every URL must be open to crawling.
When a job is no longer accepting applications, must its page be deleted and return 404 or 410?
Not necessarily. Google’s job posting guidelines list several options: set validThrough to a past date, remove the page entirely and return 404 or 410, or remove the JobPosting structured data from the page. Failing to address expired job postings promptly may result in a manual action; if you choose to keep the page, you must still ensure that the posting’s expired status is handled correctly.
References
- 暫停或停用網站 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Source used in the article above.
- 排解 Google 搜尋檢索錯誤 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Source used in the article above.
- 瞭解徵人啟事結構定義標記 | Google 搜尋中心 | Documentation | Google for Developersdevelopers.google.com — Discusses: When a job is no longer accepting applications, must its page be deleted and return 404 or 410?
- How to deal with obselete product pages on an e-commerce site?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Should a seasonal product that is temporarily out of stock return 404 or 410?
- Broken Links: Common Causes and How to Fix Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-06-07T21:58:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Will 404 errors affect search engine ranking?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Do deleted URLs still need to be crawlable by search engines?
- HTTP Status Codes Explained: Full List & Impact on SEOwww.semrush.com · 2021-03-22T15:00:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Reset / Remove - Google Keywordswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- ecommerce item deleted by user, 301 redirect to HOME PAGE or 404 not found?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.



